Yankuba Minteh (now playing for Brighton & Hove Albion)

[David Edgar]

33 minutes ago, KetsbaiaIsBald said:

I really hope we sign a quality right winger this winter so this Minteh "mistake" argument can die down.

 

 

That Minteh who plays for Brighton would be the perfect quality right winger.

[Kid Icarus]

Release clauses are triggered by buying clubs and there were none.

 

Not that that makes the idea of selling Bruno to keep Minteh and Anderson any less mental.

[AyeDubbleYoo]

20 minutes ago, The College Dropout said:

Release clause. 
 

We have a high wage bill that keeps increasing. Also have a high amortisation carry over.  
 

We’ve sold 2 out of our 3 known ‘wonderkids’. If we want to rebuild we’ll need to raise significant funds. Unless we change tact with sponsorships that will mean sales. 

Not sure either of them qualify as wonderkids but I get the point. 

[KetsbaiaIsBald]

38 minutes ago, David Edgar said:

That Minteh who plays for Brighton would be the perfect quality right winger.

Maybe.  But there are many right wingers and we needed to sell him at the time.  At the end of the day he's a kid that had one above average year in a below average European league but shows a lot of promise.  I'm sure he will do well but some of the posts on here are like he's the only decent right wing prospect in world football.  It frustrating we had to sell him, he's guaranteed to score at the weekend but he's been average at best at Brighton.  The way Howe introduces players to the team I'm not convinced he's have had much game time at all here this season.

 

I searched a Brighton forum to see what they think of him so far.  These are genuinely the first posts I found:

 

These two were after the Spurs game when he scored:

Quote

Minteh 7 - great to see him score and that will hopefully help him a lot. His League Two-dribbling needs to be sorted one way or another though because it leads to us losing possession too many times.

"will hopefully help him a lot" implies a lot about his previous games...

 

 

Quote

Minteh 4 I know he got the goal and that seemed to give him confidence but was terrible in 1st half

 

This was a bit earlier when rating their new players:

Quote

Of the new players so far Minteh has no touch or decision making

 

Our mistake was not selling him(our hands were tied) it was not signing someone else.  

 

 

 

Edited October 15, 2024 by KetsbaiaIsBald

[Lotus]

I think when people think of the horror of selling Bruno they seem to be completely overlooking the fact he would obviously be replaced by a lower profile, younger player on lower wages. Hopefully that player would have  a similar career trajectory and then we’d sell him. 
To be able to really invest serious money in the squad we either massively increase revenue (clearly extremely difficult) or we sell high and reinvest in lower value players.

If we are to grow the value of our squad that squad will need to have a transitory feel for a while.

[AyeDubbleYoo]

I don't think we're overlooking that, we just have different views on what we would prefer. 

[Lotus]

Just now, AyeDubbleYoo said:

I don't think we're overlooking that, we just have different views on what we would prefer. 

I'd prefer to keep Bruno and spend £150M.

 

But, reality…..

[TRon]

9 minutes ago, Lotus said:

I'd prefer to keep Bruno and spend £150M.

 

But, reality…..

 

This is the thing. I'm sure we'd have preferred to have kept Minteh and Anderson as well regardless of whether they turn out to be stars or flops, but because of the way PSR is rigged we had to sell someone. Selling Bruno sounds ridiculous currently, but unless we are allowed to invest big money into getting two or three key areas of the squad upgraded within the next 12-24 months we'll be selling him anyway, at diminishing returns depending on when that happens.

[AyeDubbleYoo]

14 minutes ago, Lotus said:

I'd prefer to keep Bruno and spend £150M.

 

But, reality…..

 

Well that wasn't my argument. For example, some people might prefer to keep Bruno, sell two young players and spend a bit less. It's not a no-brainer that selling our best players is the right way forward every time. 

[Lotus]

4 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

 

Well that wasn't my argument. For example, some people might prefer to keep Bruno, sell two young players and spend a bit less. It's not a no-brainer that selling our best players is the right way forward every time. 

That’s true. If, as a club you’ve committed to squad churn to achieve the maximum potential levels for squad investment then it makes sense to sell when your highest value players at their highest value.

[Lotus]

And Bruno is my favourite player.

It would kill me to see him leave. 
I'm coming to the conclusion that a Howe team is not really the best vehicle to showcase Isak’s talents to their utmost. 
I think an EH team needs a stronger striker who has a relentless engine for defensive work.

[gdm]

3 hours ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

SJP would've been surrounded by an angry mob if we'd sold Bruno to keep Anderson and a player most fans have never seen

Quite unlikely. If someone triggered Bruno’s release clause there’s fuck all anyone could do about it 

[AyeDubbleYoo]

47 minutes ago, gdm said:

Quite unlikely. If someone triggered Bruno’s release clause there’s fuck all anyone could do about it 

I assumed we were talking about taking an active decision to sell him. 

[gdm]

3 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

I assumed we were talking about taking an active decision to sell him. 

Yes but that can only happen if someone wants him and I doubt we’d sell him for under that clause value so therefor either no one wants him or someone does and would have to pay for him and trigger that clause. Unless of course you think we’d take less than the clause £100m for him

 

 

Edited October 15, 2024 by gdm

[AyeDubbleYoo]

We were talking about which is the best strategy, and the merits of selling a big name versus two younger players.

 

 

Edited October 15, 2024 by AyeDubbleYoo

[et tu brute]

51 minutes ago, gdm said:

Quite unlikely. If someone triggered Bruno’s release clause there’s fuck all anyone could do about it 

That's what the owners were thinking would happen. The amount of times this thread is updated is mad, you have one player who didn't really impress at all in the 50 games he played in and another who would have went back out on loan this season imo (he'd also actually hadn't been that impressive until the last game either). PSR is the reason they were sold, it's what we have to accept until the rules eventually do come crashing down. Anyway best for me to just keep out of this thread from now on

[Kid Icarus]

1 hour ago, gdm said:

Quite unlikely. If someone triggered Bruno’s release clause there’s fuck all anyone could do about it 

You can't both argue that we should have sold him while claiming it would happen via a release clause. It was either our responsibility or it wasn't.

 

Not saying you're saying that, but those were the two points made earlier by someone else. 

 

 

Edited October 15, 2024 by Kid Icarus

[gdm]

2 minutes ago, Kid Icarus said:

You can't both argue that we should have sold him while claiming it would happen via a release clause. It was either our response or it wasn't.

 

Not saying you're saying that, but those were the two points made earlier by someone else. 

Unless I got it wrong someone said they would sell him for £100m which was the release clause. Now if you are suggesting we sell Bruno cheap then yes that’s a different matter and would get an angry crowd at St James park

[Kid Icarus]

13 minutes ago, gdm said:

Unless I got it wrong someone said they would sell him for £100m which was the release clause. Now if you are suggesting we sell Bruno cheap then yes that’s a different matter and would get an angry crowd at St James park

 

Yes, it was his release clause amount, which is what makes any 'would sell' argument that was being made moot. It's not our responsibility for other clubs to meet a release clause.

[54]

 

[GeordieToon]

I think Arne Slot not going in for Minteh speaks volumes, He had an impresive season at Feyenoord under Slot,

But he cant rate him as a top prem player. Otherwise he would have gone in for him.

No doubt he is a very good player. but at top level, there must be doubts.

 

 

Edited October 19, 2024 by GeordieToon

[healthyaddiction]

16 minutes ago, GeordieToon said:

I think Arne Slot not going in for Minteh speaks volumes, He had an impresive season at Feyenoord under Slot,

But he cant rate him as a top prem player. Otherwise he would have gone in for him.

No doubt he is a very good player. but at top level, there must be doubts.

 

 

 

That's a hell of a stretch. A manager doesn't have to automatically buy good players he's formerly managed. Just Erik Ten Hag.

[Joe1984]

30 minutes ago, GeordieToon said:

I think Arne Slot not going in for Minteh speaks volumes, He had an impresive season at Feyenoord under Slot,

But he cant rate him as a top prem player. Otherwise he would have gone in for him.

No doubt he is a very good player. but at top level, there must be doubts.

 

 

 

He is also unproven at PL level...

[LiquidAK]

Given Liverpool will clearly need a Salah replacement in the next year or so, bringing in Minteh for a season deputising on the RW wouldn't have been that wild a concept tbf. A million reasons why they might not have gone for him though, not sure you can read that much into it (as much as I'd love the copium of it saying he's overrated). 

[stozo]

Not even good enough for Brighton's bench today. 

 

 

Edited October 19, 2024 by stozo