NUFC Transfer Rumours

[AyeDubbleYoo]

3 minutes ago, KaKa said:

 

We really haven't made any mega signings and don't need to.

 

Just need to get a player the manager rates and believes will excel in our setup.

 

Same as we have been doing already, and having success with.

Yeah, maybe I phrased that wrongly. I just meant someone who is the next level of quality and clearly likely to make it. Albeit I accept that all signings are a risk. 
 

We’re a signing away from one of the best forward lines in Europe, it might be worth going a bit bigger than the transfers we’ve made before. 
 

I trust the club either way though. 
 

Also I like Madueke in isolation and he would improve here. 

 

 

Edited July 26, 2024 by AyeDubbleYoo

[janpawel]

I think people will be in for a shock if they are thinking our starting 11 will be drastically improved / changed come the season 

 

Knowing Eddie and guessing the signing we make, I can only imagine a new RW would start. Can imagine new CB on the bench at the start, and don't forget Longstaff starting until Tonali ban has ended 🙂

[TorchyTBB]

Would be very happy with Madueke or Mbeumo, rate them both.

 

 

Edited July 27, 2024 by TorchyTBB

[The College Dropout]

1 minute ago, KaKa said:

 

We really haven't made any mega signings and don't need to.

 

Just need to get a player the manager rates and believes will excel in our setup.

 

Same as we have been doing already, and having success with.

We’ve made at least a couple mega signings and a few players for big money that are either proven or have high upside. 
 

Madueke was less productive than Minteh was in the Eredivisie. There must be better options than him for £40m. 

[Dokko]

Can we not just buy Minteh back for £40m? Seems the best option. 

[nufc123]

11 minutes ago, janpawel said:

I think people will be in for a shock if they are thinking our starting 11 will be drastically improved / changed come the season 

99% of the reports are saying a purple RW, CB to take over for Schar in the years to come, backup striker. Its only the RW who will go straight in so I dont think anyone are expecting an overhaul tbh. But I expect the RW to be far more goals/assists profilic than Madueke.

[KaKa]

12 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

Yeah, maybe I phrased that wrongly. I just meant someone who is the next level of quality and clearly likely to make it. Albeit I accept that all signings are a risk. 
 

We’re a signing away from one of the best forward lines in Europe, it might be worth going a bit bigger than the transfers we’ve made before. 
 

I trust the club either way though. 
 

Also I like Madueke in isolation and he would improve here. 

 

 

 

 

Yeah, I just think the approach has always been to sign players that are highly thought of by the manager/recruitment team and that is the priority.

 

For what it's worth, I'm not particularly keen on Madueke, but if that's who their choice is, I'm pretty certain it will work out well.

 

At one point the likes of Diaby and Szoboszlai looked like they would have been great additions, and they have proved to be pretty disappointing.

[Shearergol]

Hate the idea of giving Chelsea money.

[KaKa]

24 minutes ago, The College Dropout said:

We’ve made at least a couple mega signings and a few players for big money that are either proven or have high upside. 
 

Madueke was less productive than Minteh was in the Eredivisie. There must be better options than him for £40m. 

 

I'm really not that keen on Madueke. Chelsea paid around £30 million for him though, and so he will cost around £40 million is all I said.

 

There's enough there that I could see him doing better than expected if he signed, even though I'm not that sold on him, and so if that's their choice so be it.

 

I couldn't tell you how good the PSV team Madueke played for in the Dutch league was compared to the Feyenoord team Minteh featured in. And so not sure how best to compare them.

 

Also, Howe has now come out himself and said he was looking forward to working with Minteh this summer and evaluating him. He has himself said he didn't want to lose him.

 

We had to sell Minteh due to difficult circumstances and have done, and so I don't know why he keeps being spoken of as though we got rid of him because he wasn't wanted or rated.

 

 

Edited July 26, 2024 by KaKa

[KaKa]

Also who are these mega signings we made @The College Dropout?

[Kanj]

If we didn’t have the PSR nonsense, I’m guessing Minteh would have lined up as first choice RW. 

[geordie_b]

3 minutes ago, Kanji said:

If we didn’t have the PSR nonsense, I’m guessing Minteh would have lined up as first choice RW. 

 

If we didnt have the 'PSR nonsense' Minteh still wouldnt be at the club as we would have signed multiple players far better than him

 

 

Edited July 26, 2024 by geordie_b

[KaKa]

2 minutes ago, Kanji said:

If we didn’t have the PSR nonsense, I’m guessing Minteh would have lined up as first choice RW. 

 

If he had a good pre season, he would have certainly had a chance to. 

 

At the minimum though, he would have been a quality backup on the right, and others would have left the club.

[Unbelievable]

19 minutes ago, geordie_b said:

 

If we didnt have the 'PSR nonsense' Minteh still wouldnt be at the club as we would have signed multiple players far better than him

 

 

 

I assume people meant specifically our PSR isues late June that forced us to sell Anderson and Minteh, as opposed to PSR in general.

[The College Dropout]

34 minutes ago, KaKa said:

Also who are these mega signings we made @The College Dropout?

Tonali and Isak. Big in fee and reputation.  

 

Trippier was a massive coup at the time too.  
 

Botman and Bruno were highly rated too. Linked to some other big clubs. Maybe not mega but close. 
 

We’ve done really well in getting players top clubs were having a look at but had not pulled the trigger. And we got one from a big club and beat that same big club to another one. 

[AyeDubbleYoo]

30 minutes ago, Kanji said:

If we didn’t have the PSR nonsense, I’m guessing Minteh would have lined up as first choice RW. 

I doubt it, too early to expect him to just step in and play to such a high level. 
 

Actually I think planning to start Minteh would’ve attracted more criticism than selling him. Can imagine the posts now - young, unproven, only played well in Holland etc. 

 

 

Edited July 26, 2024 by AyeDubbleYoo

[Unbelievable]

1 minute ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

I doubt it, too early to expect him to just step in and play to such a high level. 
 

Actually I think planning to start Minteh would’ve attracted more criticism than selling him. Can imagine the posts now - young, unproven, only played well in Holland etc. 

 

 

 

Can't remember people saying such things about the likes of Anderson and Miley when they were eased in from lower league/next to no significant experience, so I think Minteh would have been given a fair crack just like everybody else coming in.

 

On a general note, Brighton, Dortmund, Lyon and the likes were happy to spend >30m on him, so perhaps we should stop pretending he'd be nowhere near ready for some first team action in a top league yeah..?

[Upthemags]

9 minutes ago, Unbelievable said:

Can't remember people saying such things about the likes of Anderson and Miley when they were eased in from lower league/next to no significant experience, so I think Minteh would have been given a fair crack just like everybody else coming in.

 

On a general note, Brighton, Dortmund, Lyon and the likes were happy to spend >30m on him, so perhaps we should stop pretending he'd be nowhere near ready for some first team action in a top league yeah..?

Bang on. There should be no shame merely admitting we planned poorly, and lost a highly sought after talent for it.

 

No one in here denies, as far as I know, that it was the right move to sell under the circumstances.

 

 

Edited July 26, 2024 by Upthemags

[Nine]

Mbeumo would be my pick of the bunch, he’s a near perfect fit for our RW spot in terms of how he would be able to contribute to the system overall as well as offering a genuine threat.

 

Im not sure how realistic he’d be though, as I doubt Brentford let both him and Toney leave in the same window. I get the feeling we may end up with an out of the blue signing for this position, someone we have seen no link to yet.

[AyeDubbleYoo]

13 minutes ago, Unbelievable said:

Can't remember people saying such things about the likes of Anderson and Miley when they were eased in from lower league/next to no significant experience, so I think Minteh would have been given a fair crack just like everybody else coming in.

 

On a general note, Brighton, Dortmund, Lyon and the likes were happy to spend >30m on him, so perhaps we should stop pretending he'd be nowhere near ready for some first team action in a top league yeah..?

 

I'm just saying that I can image extreme scepticism if Minteh was our RW signing. 

 

I wish Minteh well, I just don't get the attachment to someone who never even trained with our first team. I just always assumed he would probably sold for FFP.

[andycap]

Wages wise mbuemo will be on the least out the two wingers. 

I think he'd jump at the chance to play for us like. 

[Theregulars]

3 minutes ago, AyeDubbleYoo said:

 

I'm just saying that I can image extreme scepticism if Minteh was our RW signing. 

 

I wish Minteh well, I just don't get the attachment to someone who never even trained with our first team. I just always assumed he would probably sold for FFP.

I agree. I can't remember when, but I am sure I recall an interview where Howe said he hadn't kept particularly close tabs on him and hadn't spoken to him during his time there. At most I think they wanted to take a look pre-season based on his better-than-expected time in Holland, but I think this was always a viable option if not the option.

[KaKa]

23 minutes ago, The College Dropout said:

Tonali and Isak. Big in fee and reputation.  

 

Trippier was a massive coup at the time too.  
 

Botman and Bruno were highly rated too. Linked to some other big clubs. Maybe not mega but close. 
 

We’ve done really well in getting players top clubs were having a look at but had not pulled the trigger. And we got one from a big club and beat that same big club to another one. 

 

Okay, well I think we view mega signings differently then.

 

Because for me those are signings that are pretty much sure bankers, that are fully proven and guaranteed successes.

 

If we go out and sign an Olise or Kudus this summer for that right wing those would be mega signings.

[Toon1892]

18 minutes ago, Upthemags said:

Bang on. There should be no shame merely admitting we planned poorly, and lost a highly sought after talent for it.

 

No one in here denies, as far as I know, that it was the right move to sell under the circumstances.

 

 

 

Planned poorly!? 
 

There is no golden bullet. Buying unproven youth to sell on to make profit was the plan. It’s a very good plan to keep the proven talent. Without that plan Bruno/ Gordon/ Isak would have been sold.

 

Sorry but it is anything but poor planning. What did you want the club to do?

[Upthemags]

1 minute ago, Toon1892 said:

Planned poorly!? 
 

There is no golden bullet. Buying unproven youth to sell on to make profit was the plan. It’s a very good plan to keep the proven talent. Without that plan Bruno/ Gordon/ Isak would have been sold.

 

Sorry but it is anything but poor planning. What did you want the club to do?

Mate, if you think shopping Anthony Gordon for a desperate eleventh hour sale isn't the mark of poor planning, manifest.... I don't really know what else to say

 

Are we denying now that we played fast and loose with PSR deadlines and it almost was catastrophic?