Trying to be as objective as I can: 2/10
Lloyd Kelly is a decent signing, especially on a free transfer and in time will become a valuable squad member. However the signing feels more disappointing due to us not capitalising on his free transfer to spend money elsewhere.
William Osula I've made my opinions clear on. I don't rate him and I'm very concerned by his goal scoring record for a striker. So far he hasn't had a single second on the pitch despite being the only other available striker.
John Ruddy and Odysseas Vlachodimos - What can be said? We needed a backup goalkeeper to Pope, or at least one who could challenge him as number 1. We signed 2 goalkeepers and we still need that. Vlachodimos fee rumoured to be anywhere between £5m - £20m which is horrendous.
Elliott Anderson (out) - Maybe a good deal, but counteracted by the fact that Vlachodimos might well be eating a lot of that £35m fee making it next to no money at all. Think he should have been given another season personally and potentially the fee we got after PSR shambles is not that good.
Yankuba Minteh (out) - A promising young player who played well at Feyernoord, including in the Champions League, let go without playing a single minute for us in a position we desperately needed to strengthen. Again people dismiss this as being down to PSR but who's fault was the PSR situation in the first place?
Marc Guehi saga - Incredible amount of time and effort wasted on this transfer when it was clear fairly early on when Parish started guffawing in public about it that it wasn't going to happen. Also crazy that we were seemingly going to spend the entire budget on him when there were other positions that needed strengthening too.
We needed quality at both CB and RW and we're now left with an injury ravaged CB pool to choose from and the same ineffective RW options which have become incredibly stale.
The only deadwood that went out was Ryan Fraser right at the end of the window. I appreciate its difficult to sell shit players but it can be done as other clubs regularly prove.
The PSR shambles was something else and very concerning. Most people seem to just ignore it but its not something that should be ignored.
The biggest disappointments for me have been that the window has killed my confidence in the ability of those running the club. Their competence has to seriously come into question and they have a lot of questions to answer for this failure of a window. The mood around the club is going to be very low now and thats not fair on Eddie or the existing players to have to shoulder alone.