Sidwell wouldn't offer anything more than Parker offers really if he played in front of Butt. I'd be very disappointed if they were our first choice midfield partnership for next season. We're crying our for an attacking midfielder who scores goals. We've been missing that since Rob Lee and Gary Speeds peak really. Lets not get into a debate about who would be first choice defensive midfielder next season but i don't want to see Parker, Butt or Sidwell (if we sign him) in the same team together. Who you would have as your first choice is a different matter, but we will get nowhere playing them together.