AyeDubbleYoo

Easiest question of the year so far, of course not. He's proven not to be good enough for the Prem. A bit like Shola, except we never managed to sell Shola.

I'd like to think there must be something about Best for him to be signed... still think he'd have gone on a decent run if one of his near misses had gone in last season. Saying that, I haven't seen anything to suggest he can score more than a goal or two in the Premiership. We definitely need to sign a proper partner for Carroll.

You can, I'm just about to do it for Villa.

I don't get it... he likes cake?

I agree that the big clubs shouldn't be able to stockpile the best players, but at the same time we want home-grown players to be developed. It would be difficult to do bring your young players through if you had to sell them as soon as they had a fancy for first team football.

In the history of the game, it's very recent.

He really should concentrate on shutting his hole.

It was funny at the beginning but was probably twice as long as it needed to be.

Don't know, and almost certainly.

I'm not a massive fan of loaning players from other Premiership clubs, but if Cleverly has something about him and he helps us stay up then he's worth a go. Might be a short loan deal until Gosling is fit I suppose. Or not.

Jesus. Yeah, just what I was thinking. Oh, and woosh. Nah, nee woosh, that's what the smilie was there to prevent! Honest.

Very good point. True, although that relies on the other teams using the money wisely. For £30m you could buy at least 3 players all as good as Milner.

Commenators, co commentators and pudits saying "well there was contact, so its a pen" even tho the contact is minimal and the player chucks himself on the deck cos an arm was rubbed up against him. Of course there will be contact, players have to try and regain possesion from the opposign team, players will rub up against each other. This also brings me on to refs who dont seem to understand the basics of physics. Commentators have adapted far too easily to the new era of diving and cheating... they seem to just expect it now, and support the players doing it.

Jesus.

well said. He's left the club now so no use crying over spilt milk in any case. Im happier with jonas on te left and hopefully routledge will realise his potential on the right. Thirded. I think he was worth 5-7 million, and probably still is. Sadly transfer fees are based on hype, so he's probably 'worth' at least 20 now.

I love it, especially the way Carroll combines it with Geordie grit. Any chance of Perch or Goswell growing theirs?

OK. As well as Milner has done in the last year, it beggars belief that Villa want £30million for him. Madness. True, but it's madness to sell anyone to Man City without opening negotiations at £30m. Apart from us Yep, unless they're one of Europe's top goalkeepers, then you should obviously let them go cheap.

No, Jonas Guitterez.

I still think the Champions League should really just be the league winners (and perhaps main cup winners) of all European nations. Obviously the smaller nation champions would need to go through qualifiers to make sure it's just 32 teams in it. Shame it won't happen since no big teams = no big money. Totally agree, also the Europa League should be completely separate and not allow the Champions League failures in.

OK. As well as Milner has done in the last year, it beggars belief that Villa want £30million for him. Madness. True, but it's madness to sell anyone to Man City without opening negotiations at £30m.

Mine too. Many a time watching Newcastle you can hear cries of 'FORWAHD MAN FORWAHD!' One of my pet hates is people not understanding that football is about protecting possession as much as about getting it forward. Especially evident during the World Cup when the non-fans come out of the woodwork. Surely it’s about scoring more goals than the opposition, be that 1-0 or 3-2. How a team goes about this is matter of choice not right and wrong. Wimbledon won the FA Cup (which on a relative scale is a greater achievement than Spain winning the World Cup)and they didn’t give a shit about retaining possession. Yep, that's what I said, "as much as".

You couldn't call them high energy either.

No doubt it's special, because of the players who have worn it. If you don't buy into things like that, you're missing a lot of the appeal of football IMO. You may as well pop down to the local park on a Sunday and just watch any random football you find.

Yes you could. I don't mean he's as good as Gerrard et al, but he's arguably good enough to get into the Villa and Everton teams. Although people are right to say it has been a long time since he played up to his potential.

If he's playing regularly and up to his potential I'd say he's top 6 standard.