mozy

No replacement!

Harper 6 Saylor 6 Colo 6 Bassong 7 Enrique 7 Raylor 4 Smith 6 Geremi 5 Jonas 7.5 Loven 7 Martins 6.5

lol Mate thats an instant red, hes taken ronaldo out with an arm across the neck and then chopped vidic ? In half with a follow up tackle. He ran off to pretend it was nothing big. Bollocks, its only a red if u make contact with the face/head not a forearm to the neck.

Only 1 cunt involved in that challenge

Cole is pretty harsh, he did well when he came on. Ashley Cole was awful, that cross he looped out for a throw in instead of passing it. Barry, did he even play?

Spurs, Blackburn and Boro

Brilliant bit of business to get him for 4 million. Now lets get a pair of fullbacks and another midfielder

Given - World Class 10/10 Harper - Solid deputy 6/10 Beye - Failed to match last seasons performances 7/10 Bassong - Quality 8/10 Taylor - Always committed, if a little rash. 6/10 Collocini - Overhyped, unfortunately 6/10 Enrique - Good without the ball, useless with it 6/10 Edgar - Doesn't look up to it 4/10 Cacapa - Embarrassing 3/10 Duff - Doesn't justify his wages 6/10 N'Zogbia - Whiny little shit 6/10 Guthrie - Everything Nicky Butt isn't 7/10 Butt - You think he would learn by 33 5/10 Gutierrez - Been poor for a while 6/10 Barton - Needs to get on the field consistently 6/10 Geremi - Get rid, hes finished 4/10 Smith - 6 fucking million pounds 5/10 Viduka - Always injured, never tries 5/10 Martins - Our best player 8/10 Owen - Clearly wants out 6/10 Carroll - Looked good when he's played 7/10 Ameobi - Injury prone, 6/10 Xisco - Not given a chance 5/10 Kinnear - So much bullshit its untrue, The press must love having him feed them all this shite every fucking day. Anyone who thinks he's "steadied the ship" needs their head looked at.

Geremi is so slow and un-agile its scary. Any current premier league left winger would have a field day against him. At least Edgar has some idea of how to use his body and tackle. Geremi doesn't have the speed or energy to get up and down the flank either, similar to Stephen Carr. Would be horrific if he was played at right back.

On a par with Edgar as a right back, but both are nowhere near as good as Taylor, and Taylor is not good.

There are no other options for most of the players you criticise and you're just picking fault for the sake of it.

If you read it for the other teams, apparently Bolton and Blackburn dream of signing Nicky Butt in January. Heres hoping.....

You've actually managed to display the biggest lack of logic in argument in many a year. Congrats. explain, were talking about a team that have lost twice to spurs and drawn against west ham, hull, stoke, all at home. Im not ready to give up on newcastle. If it was our first 11 I'd like our chances of maybe nicking a draw if we played well, but as it is I'm not sure we have 11 fully fit players. Completly agree, I mean they're only challenging for the title. We're better all over the park, Butt and Duff are perfect examples of players Liverpool need to sustain a title challenge. The sooner people realise this the better, we're better than Liverpool and it's only down to luck that they're separated by twelve places in the league. Unbelievable! As clueless as his comments are, Liverpool aren't a million miles ahead of us imo. They have had a lot of games that they won by luck, late show of team spirit or other teams incompetencies/ referees. Saying that, we probably won't win tomorrow purely due to lack of squad depth. However we will be fired up after Wigan and I'm feeling pretty positive.

Nah you could tell how carefully Joe was trying to choose his words. He didnt say anything "Mickey Mouse" esque

Today was the only time he has ever looked remotely good enough. TBF looks like hes been given the same type of coaching Shola has and looks stronger and more aggressive with closing down. Could be a good player in there as he has obvious strengths

I hope JFK crucifies Mike Dean in the SSN interview so badly his is given a lifetime touchline ban

If Jonas was English, he'd be crucified. Makes me laugh how so many people can call Butt a complete waste of space five days after he was excellent against Spurs, yet Jonas gets away with being consistently mediocre Rubbish, Jonas is not consistent, which is his problem. Nicky Butt on the other hand is consistently shite, has one good game in 10

For saying the stick they get is a little over the top at times (in my opinion). This place is a joke sometimes. Dean deserves everything he gets for today. Fucking embarrassing for him.

Given - 6 World Class apart from (Ryan) Taylorgate. Beye - 6 RIP Colo - 6 solid Bassong - 6 solid as well Zog - 5 defensive 2 balanced out by attacking 8 Jonas - 5 rare off day but still worked hard Butt - 2 Total Shite Guthrie - 6.5 Everything Butt isn't and so much more. Duff - 3 Not many get burned by Mario Melchiot Owen - 3 Woefully ineffective Viduka - 3 Worse Taylor - 6 Solid Carroll - 8 Brave, energetic and committed.

Dean should be Relegated to league 2 for the foreseeable future. Worse than Styles at home to Man City Totally Wank

Andy Carrolls effort when he came on showed just how shit Owen and Viduka had been. Nothing worse than players who don't even try which is why I hate Berbatov.

Well put. I just hope this defeat doesnt go to the players hearts and they realise it was a freak game too. Strange as it feels to say it, I trust JFK totally with that. The us vs them mentality helps as well.

Its "One of these days" being played at "one of those stadiums" with "one of those players" on the other team and "one complete shit cunt" refereeing. Freak day tbh.

Jonas was shit btw

Mike Dean is a fucking cunt who had one of the worst refereeing games I have ever seen. Even Paedophile Neale Barry was never that fucking shit. I feel robbed, despite how shit we were, I still feel so fucking robbed. Well played Carrol, Zog and Guthrie for the 2nd half. Nicky Butt produced his worst ever league performance for us, Jonas was wank, Duff worse. Bassong collo and taylor were decent. Owen and Viduka were turd, shown up by the big AC. To some it up, I hope Mike Dean suffers some kind of personal trauma so that he can never referee again.