ChrisMcQuillan

It's better than yours.

That's actually stunning.

So say Coloccini is injured and Taylor suspended for a vital match. I'd rather Kadar and Williamson than have Tozer or Simpson anywhere near the CB position. We'd have sufficient depth at CB. 4 we could play with reasonable quality. I say all this assuming Williamson's an average CB.

Not the SPL mate. He did alright at Leeds in the Championship. Just look at his hat-trick against Spain if you want examples of his finishing. He would be able to do a job for us, no doubt. I actually think he was Premier League quality a few years ago. Maybe not anymore.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/s/sunderland/8470445.stm Quality finisher who will thrive with regular football. Please, PLEASE bring him in!

No wonder he wants to sign him if he thinks he played well against West Brom. Seems he can do no wrong. Hopefully the report isn't true anyway. Hughton's not a moron. He knows he was awful. But Simpson knew he was awful as well, you could see it in his face. Hughton's doing the right thing, managerially, imo, and backing the player publically.

Harper - 6 Simpson - 2 (one of the worst defensive performances I've seen from a Newcastle player in recent years) S Taylor - 7 Coloccini - 6 Enrique - 6.5 (assist redeems him for some very dodgy give-aways) Guthrie - 7 (sublime freekick, solid shift) Nolan - 4 (Was he even on the pitch?) Smith - 6 (Very quiet game, especially when we needed him to break down their attacks. However, the kamikaze shot block... ) Gutierrez - 7.5 (Man of the Match, just, simply because he stretched their defence, he caused them problems and he looked like he wasn't scared to run at them) Ameobi - 3 (woeful) Lovenkrands - 7 (good header, love the guy for playing) Carroll - 5.5 (better than Ameobi) R Taylor - 6 (at least he tackled their right wing, unlike Simpson)

Simpson was absolutely atrocious last night. Going by Newcastle's track record, any doubts we had over his good performances will be erradicated, and we'll sign him up immediately.

Being from Northern Ireland makes you British. He is still most likely from Irish heritage, but is a British citizen.

Have only managed 60 68 so far.

Not funny lol

If I were in the country, I'd be there blizzard or nay. Unfortunately, I only land back in Newcastle tomorrow evening.

It's a bit like Shearer wearing a Sunderland polo shirt, esp. after the celebration incident.

You're insane mate. No honestly, hes done absolutely nothing wrong, and his long passes that usually end up with f*** all, are accurate today. It's true. Butt's played pretty damn well.

I'd have said Watford. Just.

Right there with you, Danny.

Didnt even make the bench, no midfielders there atall Nicky Butt's magnificence is all we need.

He's gone mental, alright.

Look, it's fine. Nicky Butt is experienced, magnificent, and 24 years old. He'll dribble through their team using all his experience, and slam a shot into the roof of the net with his magnificent young leg.

See this is the problem ^ Get that guy to stay at home, ffs.

IMO... Butt -> Lovenkrands Carroll -> Ameobi

# they will attack for 10 mins, not score - lose heart. 0-3 ft. Great work, Nostradamus.

We'd have 13 players on the pitch, then. Not sure they'll allow that.

Marriage?