ponsaelius

I dont care that it was the Championship, when he played CM for us last year (for a extended period) he was solid. Give him a fking chance Rather than being 'solid', he was our best midfielder.

Hasn't played in his natural position yet this season. I'll reserve judgement as to whether he can step up this season.

Christ.

Still he should be sticking to his position of RM more than he does, did we actually create a good attack from our right-side in the 1st 50 mins Also barton can play the position well and adapt to it, why can't guthrie? Cos he's so limited as a footballer. What a crock of s*** argument. Stop defending s*** footballers man. Good footballers adapt to what they are told to do, Guthrie clearly can't adapt. Again, absolute mental argument. There are some fucking fantastic footballers that would struggle to play out of position.

Still he should be sticking to his position of RM more than he does, did we actually create a good attack from our right-side in the 1st 50 mins Also barton can play the position well and adapt to it, why can't guthrie? Cos he's so limited as a footballer. What a crock of shit argument.

Win 1-0. Carroll.

The opinion of Guthrie on this forum is ridiculous. Especially with how Nolan and Smith played today. Guthrie wasn't on the same level of shitness that Nolan and Smith showed today. Anybody with a brain can see he's not a wide player in a million years. Technique wise he's a Premier League player, however like Ronaldo has said before his physical attributes just aren't up to scratch. Not fast or strong enough and his stamina is dreadful.

See Boro got beat at home again. They're still down there like.

You can't have been watching very long. He's bad, but we've had far worse. I haven't been watching Newcastle as long as 99% on here, but I know that I can safely say he's the worst player I've seen play for us in my time. Absolutely no hyperbole either, comfortably the worst. Rozehnal, Cacapa and Butt were worse in recent years, to name but a few. Not defending Smith, cause he was awful today. Nope. All 3 were better players than Smith.

Ridiculous thread. Would be better than Smith mind.

Only fucker that turned up today.

You can't have been watching very long. He's bad, but we've had far worse. I haven't been watching Newcastle as long as 99% on here, but I know that I can safely say he's the worst player I've seen play for us in my time. Absolutely no hyperbole either, comfortably the worst.

Completely and utterly out of his depth.

Worst performance in years.

Haha.

Most ridiculous cliché ever, that one.

Best player ever yuh.

wut. Well their first aim is to keep the ball. I may be an idiot but I find it boring watching a team trying to pass it into the net. Keeping the ball is the fundamental aim of football. If you find that process being performed to the highest quality boring then you're watching the wrong sport.

wut.

Odonkor Absolute definition of a speed merchant.

Yeah, Dave!

He likes that chipped floaty cross to the far post. Never really comes to anything, but I think he does it to create the illusion of having some kind of intelligence/technique to his game.

Chamakh has been a bargain for Arsenal.

He can jusitify Vuckic' -9 and Moyo's -8 because he made the first team so unplayably rubbish.

Erm.