I see both sides of this argument, but do you really think the game nowadays is anywhere near "au naturale"? Something needs to be done to make the game more honest, perhaps this is the way...
In terms of what happens on the pitch, bar goal-line technology & the odd use of extra officials, the game is still the same at every level.
Re making the game more honest, I'm all for the retrospective execution of diving cheats etc
Might be a little too far, that.