Jump to content

Milner, sell or keep


Skirge
 Share

Should we sell Milner in the transfer window ?  

204 members have voted

  1. 1. Should we sell Milner in the transfer window ?

    • SELL
    • KEEP
    • LOAN OUT AGAIN


Recommended Posts

This could be a close poll.

I know a lot on here highly rate Milner but for me his crossing is as poor as can be.

I cannot fault the lads effort or drive but when all of that comes to nothing time after time its just not good enough.

His corners hit the first man or go out of play on the other side, we are never going to score goals with crosses and corner like that.

If Villa are willing to give us good money for him and we havea player  lined  as a replacement then I would sell him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Toongaboom

            Given

 

Solano Moore Ramage Milner

Dyer    Parker Zoggy  Duff

        Sibierski

                      Martins

     

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest the_guv_nor

Sell if Roeder stays, keep if we get a new manager in.

if you were going to get rid of milner under roeder we could sell Duff, because duff has been far worse than milner.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Action Verb

Sell, or play just off the frontman. Because as a crosser of the ball he's woeful.

 

Palermo?

 

One good game and cross from how many? How many times have people been moaning about his inability to beat his man or wrap a decent cross round?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Sell if Roeder stays, keep if we get a new manager in.

if you were going to get rid of milner under roeder we could sell Duff, because duff has been far worse than milner.

 

True enough.  Anyone could be candidates for a sale under him, he's making some of our better players look distinctly average.  Much like a previous manager did...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest the_guv_nor

Sell if Roeder stays, keep if we get a new manager in.

if you were going to get rid of milner under roeder we could sell Duff, because duff has been far worse than milner.

 

True enough.  Anyone could be candidates for a sale under him, he's making some of our better players look distinctly average.  Much like a previous manager did...

 

the problem is the positions Roeder is playing the likes of Duff and Milner, when milner plays on the wing he is cutting into the centre to much in my oppinion, he should be playing on the wing whipping in the crosses like nobby used to.

Duff as played Right wing, Left wing, left back and as a striker... i dont think he knows whether he is coming or going.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I can only think the problem with Milner is a knock-on effect of the low confidence in the team as a whole. That or the effect of the transfer deadline day badness.

 

He was absolutely excellent for us last season, our best player by a mile, he's young and highly promising and will only get better. Duff is a quality player, too. These aren't players who have suddenly got shit, they're players who are playing badly and not being motivated by the manager to do any better.

 

Getting shot of the players isn't the answer (much as I'd like Milner back), getting shot of the manager is.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I can only think the problem with Milner is a knock-on effect of the low confidence in the team as a whole. That or the effect of the transfer deadline day badness.

 

He was absolutely excellent for us last season, our best player by a mile, he's young and highly promising and will only get better. Duff is a quality player, too. These aren't players who have suddenly got shit, they're players who are playing badly and not being motivated by the manager to do any better.

 

Getting shot of the players isn't the answer (much as I'd like Milner back), getting shot of the manager is.

 

Spot on. I know its what he does for us that counts but some people fail to see he actually has a lot of quality and this was proved by his stint with your lot!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Milner is the fucking reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Milner is the ****ing reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

 

Maybe a touch huh!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest the_guv_nor

Milner is the ****ing reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

[/quote

did you see him play for villa last year?

he didnt take a free kick today!

Link to post
Share on other sites

             Given

 

Solano Moore Ramage Milner

Dyer     Parker Zoggy   Duff

         Sibierski

                       Martins

       

 

no place for Taylor, Owen or Emre  :lol: :lol:

and Solano and Milner as fullbacks?  blueconfused.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest the_guv_nor

Milner is the ****ing reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

 

Did you see him playing for villa last year?

he didnt take a free kick today.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Milner is the ****ing reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

 

Did you see him playing for villa last year?

he didnt take a free kick today.

I did see him play for Villa last year. Never rated him that highly then, thought he looked decent, but nothing more.

I know he didn't take a free kick, but he was still there and wanted to take them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...