Jump to content

Chelsea (Carling Cup) - Pre-match thread


Newcastle Fan
 Share

Recommended Posts

of course the game in next wednsday

 

do  u think roeder should throw the likes of harper,luque in and give them a chance

 

or just play with our starting 11 for watford

 

here's my formation for this match

 

Given

 

Huntington  Taylor  Ramage Duff (might do,better then baba thats for sure)

 

Dyer    Butt    Parker    Milner

 

                    Sibreski

 

                              Martins

 

subs:

 

Harper

rossi

luque

emre

babayaro

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest black n white

hopefully emre will be fit, i would drop le sib and play dyer up front and put parker on the right with butt and emre in the middle

 

                    given

 

huntington taylor ramage  duff

 

parker    butt    emre  milner

 

              dyer    martins

Link to post
Share on other sites

hopefully emre will be fit, i would drop le sib and play dyer up front and put parker on the right with butt and emre in the middle

 

                    given

 

huntington taylor ramage  duff

 

parker    butt    emre  milner

 

              dyer    martins

Why would you drop sib to play parker our of position?

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd play Butt at left back ahead of Duff any day.

 

Duff is in shocking form at the moment and when he played at left-back before he was shiiiiiiiiiite, he'd be a total liability against chelsea, he'd get ripped to shreds against anyone they played against him. Butt is nowhere near ideal but he'd be a damn site better than Duff.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd play Butt at left back ahead of Duff any day.

 

Duff is in shocking form at the moment and when he played at left-back before he was shiiiiiiiiiite, he'd be a total liability against chelsea, he'd get ripped to shreds against anyone they played against him. Butt is nowhere near ideal but he'd be a damn site better than Duff.

 

I forgot that time Nicky Butt played full-back for Ireland...  Oh wait!!!  :winking:  Duff will come good and especially against Chelski.

 

I'd play this:

 

                    given

 

huntington taylor ramage  duff

 

dyer    butt    emre  milner

 

              sib    martins

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd play Butt at left back ahead of Duff any day.

 

Duff is in shocking form at the moment and when he played at left-back before he was shiiiiiiiiiite, he'd be a total liability against chelsea, he'd get ripped to shreds against anyone they played against him. Butt is nowhere near ideal but he'd be a damn site better than Duff.

 

I forgot that time Nicky Butt played full-back for Ireland...  Oh wait!!!  :winking:  Duff will come good and especially against Chelski.

 

I'd play this:

 

                    given

 

huntington taylor ramage  duff

 

dyer    butt    emre  milner

 

              sib    martins

 

 

 

 

It doesn't matter how many times he's done it, or who for, he's still shite at it!!

 

I remember Vinny Jones playing in goal for Wimbledon, doesn't mean I'd recruit the short-lived-hollywood-fad to fill in for Shay, if he had the sniffles or something.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd play Butt at left back ahead of Duff any day.

 

Duff is in shocking form at the moment and when he played at left-back before he was shiiiiiiiiiite, he'd be a total liability against chelsea, he'd get ripped to shreds against anyone they played against him. Butt is nowhere near ideal but he'd be a damn site better than Duff.

 

I forgot that time Nicky Butt played full-back for Ireland...  Oh wait!!!  :winking:  Duff will come good and especially against Chelski.

 

I'd play this:

 

                    given

 

huntington taylor ramage  duff

 

dyer    butt    emre  milner

 

              sib    martins

 

 

 

 

It doesn't matter how many times he's done it, or who for, he's still shite at it!!

 

I remember Vinny Jones playing in goal for Wimbledon, doesn't mean I'd recruit the short-lived-hollywood-fad to fill in for Shay, if he had the sniffles or something.

 

So, you're saying you'd rather play somebody who's not featured for his country at a position Duff has played before adequately on the INTERNATIONAL level?

 

I'm sorry, but that just doesn't make sense.  Duff is not a shite player, he's proved himself in the past and will come good for our club.  This is a big game for him against Chelski, he'll be his former self.  I'm pulling for him as I've always rated him. 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest black n white

id rather have dyer upfront with martins than sib, sib has been excellent but never seems to last the whole 90, butt has earned his place in cm but with parker returning from injury and the fact that he has'nt been on top form lately i would stick him on the right

Link to post
Share on other sites

This cup means more us then is does to them, I can see him resting alot of his squad for this game.

We will field our strongest side I think, no qualter given no one rested.

 

------------------Given

Hunty----Taylor------Ram-------Baba

 

Milner-----Butt------Parker-------Duff

 

-----------Martins-----Dyer

 

BENCH

Pav

Luque

Emre

Patison

Le Sib

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

This cup means more us then is does to them, I can see him resting alot of his squad for this game.

We will field our strongest side I think, no qualter given no one rested.

 

------------------Given

Hunty----Taylor------Ram-------Baba

 

Milner-----Butt------Parker-------Duff

 

-----------Martins-----Dyer

 

BENCH

Pav

Luque

Emre

Patison

Le Sib

 

 

baba is suspended

 

I would rather not have dyer on the right, he is much better in amore advanced role but i appreciate we have no one else. Maybe he will play emre (if fit) and milner on the wings and dyer upfront with martins

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest tobiazvanderziaz

                  Given

 

Milner  Taylor  Ramage    Duff

 

Dyer  Parker  Butt    Emre

 

              Martins  Sib

Link to post
Share on other sites

                  Given

 

Milner   Taylor   Ramage    Duff

 

Dyer   Parker   Butt    Emre

 

              Martins  Sib

 

no way would i play milner at right back, he looses the ball more than any other player!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest tobiazvanderziaz

Dont think he will loose the ball as much as RB and I really think Huntington together with Ramage was one of the main reasons why our build up play against Watford didnt work. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact that Luque stormed off in the huff at the weekend means he's unlikely to appear on the bench again never mind the first 11.

 

 

i think he did it before :D

 

and i think roeder just defended him today!!,saying that he saw chelsea players leave the stadium when they were not selected for the newcastle game..

Link to post
Share on other sites

The fact that Luque stormed off in the huff at the weekend means he's unlikely to appear on the bench again never mind the first 11.

 

 

i think he did it before :D

 

and i think roeder just defended him today!!,saying that he saw chelsea players leave the stadium when they were not selected for the newcastle game..

That's right it is the 2nd time he's done it. Maybe that was his last chance. Where has Roeder defended him today? Even if he has, it just shows Roeder isn't an idiot like Souness. Souness slagged off players in the press who he wanted to sell therefore reducing the price.

 

PS Who are you going to bang on about for the rest of the season if Luque is sold/loaned out in the transfer window?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Forgot about Baba's ban, so Duf at LB it is then.

--------------------Given

 

Hunty-------Taylor-----Ramage------Duff

 

Milner-------Parker-------Butt--------Emre

 

-------------Martins--------Dyer

 

yep thats what i wuld go for, a bench of

 

pav

sib

patt

luque

?

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...