Jump to content

Best player at each Premiership club.


James

Recommended Posts

Guest Toon83

Newcastle - Taylor

 

Is that some sort of sick joke?

 

hahahahaha indeed

 

agree with him about Drogba though, by far a better player than Lampard and Terry

 

No Joke, i see Taylor as our captain next season leading not only our team but our back four aswell, this is all about opinions so dont shoot me down for having mine

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree. Given is our most consistent player but if there was one player i would want to keep it is Taylor because he is a young talented geordie defender and they are rare.

 

Milner would be up there as well mind, and that little welsh bloke that gets injured.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Aston Villa- Young

 

Villa - Carew

 

Young is a fantastic prospect, and Carew a very talented footballer, but Gareth Barry was by some way our best, most consistent player last year.

 

I haven't seen a massive amount of Newcastle last year, but when I have seen you, Milner has looked your best player pretty much every time.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Our best player just left. Signed for Pompey on a free.  :weep:

 

Probably leaves Richards as our new best player. Majority of City fans would say Dunne - and would have done before any recent exits - hell he won player of the year in SWP's last season here ( :idiot2:) but...game of opinions isn't it.

 

For what its worth I think Newcastle's best player is blatantly Michael Owen.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Newcastle - Taylor

 

Is that some sort of sick joke?

 

hahahahaha indeed

 

agree with him about Drogba though, by far a better player than Lampard and Terry

 

No Joke, i see Taylor as our captain next season leading not only our team but our back four aswell, this is all about opinions so dont shoot me down for having mine

 

i know but come on.........Taylor's an average defender

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest sittingontheball

For what its worth I think Newcastle's best player is blatantly Michael Owen.

 

Sad but true. Sad because we've not seen much for our money and may not get any more.

 

Drogba's way ahead of Terry for me. Possibly Cech is too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

For what its worth I think Newcastle's best player is blatantly Michael Owen.

 

Sad but true. Sad because we've not seen much for our money and may not get any more.

 

Drogba's way ahead of Terry for me. Possibly Cech is too.

 

if terry wasn't english people would be shouting his name from rooftops man

Link to post
Share on other sites

For what its worth I think Newcastle's best player is blatantly Michael Owen.

 

Sad but true. Sad because we've not seen much for our money and may not get any more.

 

Drogba's way ahead of Terry for me. Possibly Cech is too.

 

if terry wasn't english people would be shouting his name from rooftops man

 

irrelevant, Dogba's twice the player

Link to post
Share on other sites

For what its worth I think Newcastle's best player is blatantly Michael Owen.

 

Sad but true. Sad because we've not seen much for our money and may not get any more.

 

Drogba's way ahead of Terry for me. Possibly Cech is too.

 

if terry wasn't english people would be shouting his name from rooftops man

 

irrelevant, Dogba's twice the player

 

pish

Link to post
Share on other sites

aye righto, wind back to before last season when drogba wasn't winning them matches

 

he had an immense season last season but prior that he was considered an overly-expensive diving/collapsible striker who missed too many one on ones and missed too many easy chances - if he was the striker you all claim he was they simply wouldn't have bought shevchenko, the irony being that it was obviously the competition that got him to step up his game

 

it's amazing how recent form clouds perceptions

 

terry (and lampard) have been carrying the club since ranieri and trophy's...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest nufc_geordie

n my opinion:

 

Arsenal - Thierry Henry

Close between him and Fabregas for is a world class talent, needs to prove it again next season though

 

Aston Villa - Gareth Barry

Good player, deserved better with respect to England call ups.

 

Birmingham - Cameron Jerome

Still a bit raw but the talent and goalscoring ability is there.

 

Blackburn Rovers - David Bentley

A well schooled talent from Arsenal, will only improve with more premiership experience.

 

Bolton - El Hadji Diouf

Tempermental but quality.

 

Charlton - Darren Bent

Goal scorer in a poor team.

 

Chelsea - John Terry

Best centre half in the world for me, deserves England captaincy.

 

Derby - Steve Howard

Proven goal scorer at every level he has played at, I expect him to do well in the premiership.

 

Everton - Mikel Arteta

Should be playing for a better team than Everton. Sticks out like a sore thumb.

 

Fulham - Brian McBride

Indicates to me the problems the team have when an ageing American striker is there best performer over the season

 

Liverpool - Steven Gerrard

Only other contender for England captain with Terry. Brilliant world class player.

 

Manchester City - Micah Richards

I expect him to replace Gary Neville in the near future in the England team.

 

Manchester United - Cristiano Ronaldo

Won every award going last season and thoroughly deserved them. Great to watch even if he is a pr*ck.

 

Middlesborough - Jonathan Woodgate

Class act when fit, would be just partnering John Terry for England if he could stay fit in my opinion.

 

Newcastle United - Shay Given

Probably our only world class performer at the moment.

 

Portsmouth - Matt Taylor

Must be knocking on the England door. Could easily play for a top 4 team.

 

Reading - Nicky Shorey

Thorouhly deserved his England call-up.

 

Sheffield United - Phil Jagielka

Another who can play at a higher level than Sheff Utd.

 

Sunderland - Dean Whitehead

A poor mans Steven Gerrard style performer.

 

Tottenham Hotspur - Dimitar Berbatov

Class personified. Has it all, could walk into almost any strikeforce in Europe.

 

West Ham - Carlitos Tevez

Showed his class to keep these muppets up last season.

 

Wigan - Leighton Baines

Another lefty in with England contention.

 

Watford - Jay DeMerritt

Very good centre half who could play in the premiership.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Arsenal - Henry

Aston Villa - Barry

Birmingham - McShefrey

Blackburn - McCarthy

Bolton - Anelka

Chelsea - Drogba

Derby - Barnes

Everton - Arteta

Fulham - McBride

Liverpool - Gerrard

Man City - Richards

Man Utd - Ronaldo

Middlesbrough - Woodgate

Newcastle - Owen

Portsmouth - Mendes

Reading - Shorey

Sunderland - Edwards

Tottenham - Berbatov

West Ham - Tevez

Wigan - Baines

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest optimistic nit

Reading-Doyle

 

I can see where you and others are getting at with Doyle, but I think Shorey shaded it due to the fact that he didn't fade away in the second half of the season. However football is all opinions.

 

didn't doyle get injured though? hardly his fault lyke.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest kingdawson

Arsenal - Henry

Aston Villa - Barry

Birmingham - McShefrey

Blackburn - McCarthy

Bolton - Anelka

Chelsea - Essien

Derby - Barnes

Everton - Arteta

Fulham - McBride

Liverpool - Gerrard

Man City - Richards

Man Utd - Ronaldo

Middlesbrough - Woodgate

Newcastle - Given

Portsmouth - Mendes

Reading - Shorey

Sunderland - Edwards

Tottenham - Berbatov

West Ham - Tevez

Wigan - Baines

 

 

Almost identical to mine.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of the comments to 'justify' the choices are quite funny :lol:

 

Terry is 'most influential' - so what? Does that make him the 'best'? Firstly there should be a criterion set up so that we can argue based on that criterion, and so we can avoid people just throwing random names and justifying it with 'deserves England captaincy' - :lol: what the hell does England have to do with being a 'best' player at a club?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Agree with what most people have said though I'd go for King at Spurs ahead of Berbatov. People are going to laugh at this but I'd go for Viduka as our best player now. Give Owen his due he scores on the big stage but his league goals are nothing special. Been on the scene for 10 years and never scored 20 league goals and his team play is nothing special.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Arsenal - Fabregas

Aston Villa - Barry

Birmingham - McSheffrey

Blackburn - McCarthy

Bolton - Anelka

Chelsea - Drogba

Derby - Barnes

Everton - Lescott

Fulham - McBride

Liverpool - Gerrard

Man City - Richards

Man Utd - Ronaldo

Middlesbrough - Woodgate

Newcastle - Owen

Portsmouth - Distin

Reading - Shorey

Sunderland - Edwards

Tottenham - Berbatov

West Ham - Tevez

Wigan - Baines

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...