Because either every outfield player coincidentally had poor form last season or no outfield player can operate effectively in that shamble of a regime. Occam's razor suggests the latter. I'd be reluctant to lay into any player too heavily for their poor form because it can't be discerned whether they've been unprofessional/uncommitted/thick or because of Pardew.
FWIW, it won't matter much whether Cabaye goes or not IMO.
Many of these players might had over achieved you know during 11/12. Its happened countless times in football and will happen again.
Many of them didn't. Some, perhaps. Fact is we have a core group of very good players. A group of players who've all suddenly turned bad? No chance. Beren is spot on.
See, nobody's saying this. Happens too much on here, people use a extreme, way off the mark view to support something tenuously related at best.