Lotus

Not a player I’d be thinking about selling at all. He’s feeling his way back in and we’re a little dysfunctional atm which doesn’t help.

I wouldn’t get too excited. Wham were totally defeatist by the time Hall came on. If Trips is fit to start I wouldn’t be surprised to see some permutation that means Hall is on the bench again. And, tbh it would probably be for a good reason. He made some good blocks when he came on but it was mostly high up the pitch. I do trust Howe to judge if he’s ready to be positionally sound when defending our box.

Aye, wasn’t his best performance. He’s probably playing below the standard of Jeff Hendrick atm. Maybe he needs a bit of a rest.

Delighted for him like but Wham were all over the place. Need to see him have a few good games before knowing if he’s significantly improved.

Surprised WHam didn’t get tighter to him when he came deep. They were even more disorganised than we were for a while. Would’ve like to see Isak have more goal threat throughout the game. But if you’re not, getting an assist and scoring 2 penalties is pretty awesome tbh.

Reckon Howe’s played a blinder by holding him back. Like Pardew did with Ben Arfa ?

Although, given illness to Miggy and that Murphy and Barnes would still have been on return protocols it may that there just wasn’t another option. Just speculating though. Barnes and Murphy could’ve been given the all clear for all I know. You defo did call out Gordon as being overworked prior to all this.

Alhamdulillah

EH must be absolutely shattered. For his mental health I hope there is no downward pressure on league position this year and he can concentrate on performances with a view to next year. Feels like he’s had to spend far too much of this season choosing between bad and worse. Must be incredibly taxing. I understand how it helps our profile having some form of European football regularly. Will help recruitment imo. Players will become used to seeing the club playing against continental teams. I’m sure that will help. But this year just feels like a write off. If they believe he is our SAF then have to give him a bye this season after everything. If they have doubts though or all the board are not aligned there’s gonna be a weird atmosphere at the club.

This is not apropos of Gordon but as muscles are fatigued some of the stress and load is transferred to tendons and ligaments. I did my quadriceps tendon this way. Overloading. Muscle was not recovering in time between workouts. Volume was too high (for me). One movement too far and the tendon ended up taking a load it was not designed for. Tear. This is not controversial. Re: Gordon, no idea. He’s played a lot. Too much imo given how much he sprints. I thought his hamstring would go at some point. I was wrong about that though. Hope he’s back asap. Crucial player.

Long term thinking is the only way I think. Your last paragraph is bang on too. I just want the coach who can grow the team. It’ll be great if we already have the right person in place, obvs. I just haven’t the nous to know who’s right if I’m honest. I knew Pardew was full of shit because he and I have a lot in common like that so i could tell straight away. But I don’t know good from great. I suspect it’s a lot to do with being at the right club at the right time. When you’re very emotionally invested in a sporting project it’s all too easy to get caught up in the smaller picture. The most reward is winning on match day not whether a training centre upgrade is in the pipeline or some new junior wunderskout is about to join. But as you say, those very key elements will have a far bigger say than another bad 90 mins in South London.

Well, we can disagree. I like Fernandes as a player and wished he played for us. But, it’s all moot I guess.

How did you feel about Anthony Gordon when he was at Everton?

I think, of our current midfielders, Bruno, Sandro and Willockinho will be the best blend. Should be careful paying anyone in the midfield who isn’t those 3 (or a better newcomer) top wages.

I think the transformation of Anthony Gordon is a great template for any young player who wants to achieve their potential. The player has to want it though, want it bad, real bad….

Think Garner looks a very decent player.

Can’t agree. He’s very competitive, great engine, tactical awareness and an incredible range of passing. Him instead of Longstaff would be like having 12 players on the pitch.

Bruno Fernandes is an excellent player. Would walk into our team.

As an alternative I’m pretty sure some years go Simeone had AM playing in such a way that the 2 forwards did very little defensive work. They saved their legs and all their explosiveness for opportune moments with the ball. The other 8 really had to put a shift in. It’s a system that’s probably very dependent on the players you have available.

I understand the point that if our main striker is not available for 75% of our games, given the fee and the likely wages it isn't an investment that's adequately paying off. However, I think Isak is such a rare breed of player that it's worth persevering with him and/or changing his role so he doesn't knacker himself chasing the ball as it's played between the opposite back 5. From an attacking perspective I think the idea of Gordon and a quality RWF popping up in No. 10 or CF positions and allowing Isak to drift around a little bit would bring out the best in him.

Think that's unfair. He's shown he can play in this league. He has some limitations but his engine is excellent when he's fit and that is worth something. Is certainly is in EH's system anyway.

Thought he showed a good engine in extra time. Looks like he’s getting his fitness back. His ability to run and run is his only advantage over any other journeyman so I’m hoping he gets his distance legs back. He’ll be playing for the remainder of the season so I hope he runs enough to make a difference.

I know I was guilty earlier on in the thread but we have so little information that all speculation has proved pointless. I don’t even acknowledge his existence anymore, tbh. He’s a non factor that as of yet, hasn’t cost anything as far as I know. I’ve no idea what circumstances could change that and I’m bored of guessing.

Defensively decent but offered very little going forward, unfortunately.

Not unusual for players who’ve been out for a long while to have a storming game back and then a few sub par performances. Adrenaline gets them through the 1st one. After that the lack of match sharpness takes a while. He’ll look better in 2-3 weeks. Same with Willock.