This line of argument really bugs me. Just because he hasn't juggled one into the net or airkicked on a backpass doesn't mean he's therefore immune from any other kind of critique. His kicking is shite and he's very weak at dealing with low shots into the corner of the net; and that's regardless of how bad or good the defending leading up to chances is fwiw.
He's solid enough and is "fine" for now as the best of the bunch we have, but we sorely need an upgrade at the next possible opportunity; Woodman, or a new guy.