jonny1403

I’d do that, half my mates are West Ham fans

Agree with all of that except that seems incredibly generous for Iraola to rank him alongside De Zerbi and Howe. He's taken a lower mid table team and has them...lower mid table. It's early days and there's slight improvement but I wouldn't say he's earned Tier 3 yet.

Barnes has literally contributed more than ASM this season already in less than a third of the appearances

And Burn

I'm not saying we'll catch them. You said Man U would need to collapse completely for us to catch them, which obviously isn't true.

We're four points behind Man U with easier fixtures in the run-in? Why would that need a collapse on their part?

You don’t get paid more for going on loan. He’d still be under the original contract with us.

NUFC.com says he was just rested for Blackburn and will be back for Wolves.

And you have missed my point completely as well - which is that saying he offers pure end product and not much else is an absolutely pointless comment when you haven't seen anywhere near enough of him to make that assessment. What are you basing that on? He started 3 or 4 games at the start of the season and that's it. Maybe actually give him some time to see what type of winger he can be when fully up to speed instead of trying to make any sort of analysis at this stage?

Of course he's not at his best form - he's started one game since September and has come back from 6 months out. Saying he looks like a poor player and isn't in the best form every time he comes off the bench for 30 minutes is just an absolutely pointless comment at this stage.

Absolutely nailed it. You think people would have learned after Gordon but it doesn't stop people rehasing half-baked criticisms after the lad has played less than 10 games for us, most off the bench after a long term injury. Sometimes I think our fanbase deserves everything we get.

Don't encourage touting man.

Scores a crucial equaliser v Luton. 'Hasn't been as clinical as you'd expect'

Already scored more goals than ASM last season in about 1/10th of the appearances man

I’d pay £30 million for Luke O Nien let alone Lewis Hall if it meant we win a cup.

Single-handedly took us through today. A lot of humble pie due again on this board.

Eh? We got the ball back after that

Surely Isak and Willock won't start. Starting Isak twice in 3 days after the injuries he's had this season is idiotic.

I don't think sitting on Chelsea's bench is any indication of quality like. You (and 99% of Newcastle fans) have absolutely no idea how good he is and whether it was a good decision to let him go. The Chelsea fans were similarly fuming last summer when we signed Hall ffs

Tom Davies is a bellend

Minteh is the definition of a Brighton style transfer tbh. also it takes time to set up a scouting network like brightons - he’s not travelling around the world looking for these players himself

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11667/13071448/dan-ashworth-manchester-united-planning-formal-approach-to-newcastle-for-sporting-director

What have you seen from Karius that makes you think he'd be better than Dubs? Dubs has had some poor games mixed in with some very solid/good performances.

The red card doesn't reset the yellows to zero.