So, since you seem to be involved in another discussion on an in form player where you seem to be much more level headed, would you classify Tiote as the best defensive midfielder in England at this point in time, or would you agree that would be a bit of a knee jerk?
Tiote hasn't been head and shoulders the best midfielder in England for the past 4 months.
Neither has Carroll been "head and shoulders the best center forward" in that period mate...
He most certainly has.