Anyone who rates Dummett is clearly an idiot.
Like the bloke in your avatar you mean?
We both know that if the time comes that the forum starts rating him at the level that you do, you'll do a complete heel turn on him and insist that he's a terrible coward.
I don't even rate him that highly. Good defender and a good lad, but a poor footballer. Definitely the type you want at the club, though.