arnonel

gutted. is this what a knife in the back feels like. thanks Carrol you twat

I think we need at least 3 more Carrol threads today

The good news in all of this is that once the deadline is over. These numbers will price people out of any future bids. i hope................

Value is subjective. Value is what someone else is prepared to pay. Our valuation of Bent, and Aston Villa's valuation im guessing are very different. The market value of Carrol may be around 15-20mill. Our valuation is somewhat more. He is young. Local. Lowish wages. 5 year contract. Our value of him is very high. Our value of Rooney may be lower, because of his form, his wages, etc. Get the point. Anyways. I would probably still take Rooney. My hope was to spark some discussion around Carrols VALUE. I can only count 3 players I would take in the entire league in a straight swop.

I dont think Carrol is anywhere near Rooney, but would you still take him in a straight swop? Considering he is on 120K + wages. That would mean, with our current finances, that we would need to sell or weaken other areas of the team.

, and there are 2 or 3 others, but no more. Put a value on those. Look at Bent at £23 mill. His value lies in there somewhere....

Here's a thought. How many of the current premier league strikers would you take as a straight swop for Carrol? There arent many. There-in lies his true value

The only person this will unsettle is crouch

Nolan has been hated on here as well, until recent months

Its the Toon way. We do well. We are the best. We do badly. We are the worst. Player scores a goal. Best the world has ever seen. Player makes mistake. He should be shot. Manager wins a game. Messiah. Manager loses a game. Manager Out.

imagine we got rid of him as most wanted. might have been a different season.

WHOOOOOOOOOOOOOO HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

The only thing smith will be useful for today is a half time tunnel bust up

please dear budda, when smith has the ball, and has a mackem in front of him..... please... please... please... dont panic and roll it straight to him.... please....

Better than anyone we have other than Carrol Capello scouts must also have seen something in him not a gamble if cheap and a good edition if Carrol is out

Blessing in disguise Why would we spend money and wages on someone that is only ever so slightly better than Raylor? Raylor cant beat his man Raylor has a good cross Raylor is a dead ball specialist Rather spend the few pennies we have where its absolutely urgent

its time for a smith boycoutt

its a good thing we rested our first team, they will be fresh and full of confidence going in to the next game

id even take harper for smith

Loan Smith to Leeds 0% wages No recall option We pay them 200k to take him

waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahahahahahah @ smith shocking

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u1VEY7ndKCs

or give joey a role game in the middle, loven down left, and ranger on

its amazing how slow and uncreative our midfield is with smith in it whats the point of having a midfield if we just hoof it? rather stick on an extra striker and hoof over the midfield

Great News