Please, I'm not stupid.
Why would i judge a players ability on how he copes with Championship standard football?
Now he is playing in a real competetive league he is useless,nothing he has done this season has impressed me, not even as much as a good pass.. not one..
You said Guthrie is not fit for Championship football, despite being arguably our best midfielder last season and our highest assist contributor. This in a team that finished top of the Championship, so quite evidently he is fit fot Championship football.
Smith, on the other hand looked out of his depth last season. The man offers nothing, nothing going forward, nothing defensively...absolutely fuck all. He's a complete trainwreck of a footballer and useless in every sense. How anybody can think he has ANY redeeming footballing features in beyond me. The man is a waste of a shirt number.
Guthrie, yeah probably out of his depth at this level and limited physically. However he pisses all over that fraud Alan Smith all day and all night fucking long.