Nah. Krul's distribution was shocking, his shot stopping and handling are/were good, but he rarely commanded his area (bit like Shay, except Shay was one of the GOAT's when it came to shot stopping).
Harper, nah. He was too slow. Decent enough allrounder but should have left us and played more often in the Prem. Dubs doesn't let Xabi Alonso score past him from his own half.
Pav was the weak link in the sides he was in, can't remember a great deal about him if I'm honest.
Hislop is the only one you could really argue. I remember him being steady, only reason he left was because we signed Shay.