Jump to content

Steve Harper


Tooj

Recommended Posts

A couple of things have sprung to me as of late with regards to Harper.

 

Since he's become first choice he seems to be very sluggish to react to things and probably could do with being a bit lighter. At times he appears very hesitant when making decisions. Although he did make a couple of canny saves yesterday from what I remember.

 

Also his kicking is now as bad as Given's, or it appears to be. Now I also used to remember him having quite good distribution, but it's just aimless punts to Martins, that at times go nowhere near him, or despite his leap it's pointless aiming long balls at Martins all day long. There has been plenty of opportunities for him to take a goal kick quick and knock it out to a defender, yet he never does this. Which then gives the opposition time to regroup and reorganize. I'm not sure if it's tactical mind, but just what I see happening.

Link to post
Share on other sites

In his first game back he was throwing the ball out to defenders to start playing from the back which all proper football sides do, now he's gradually punting it upfield more and more just like Given did. I don't know whether that's due to instruction or just playing safe. Otherwise he is what he is - a competent keeper who will do an unspectacular job. Krul and Forster are probably much more gifted but are inexperienced.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of his save yesterday where class,

 

Every thread at the minute is ripping into players we should try and put this past us and get behind them 150% to try and keep us up.

 

getting on cases is only going to make things worse

Link to post
Share on other sites

Some of his save yesterday where class,

 

Every thread at the minute is ripping into players we should try and put this past us and get behind them 150% to try and keep us up.

 

getting on cases is only going to make things worse

 

I get behind them at the match though. I come on here to talk about things and criticise if needs be. But just because someone is wearing the shirt doesn't mean to me on here they're exempt from criticism.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest toonlass

Harper has made some cracking saves, but I agree that at times he seems hesitant and then looks a bit panicky when he has decided what he is going to do. Despite that though I think he is still a great keeper and will come good.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harper has made some cracking saves, but I agree that at times he seems hesitant and then looks a bit panicky when he has decided what he is going to do. Despite that though I think he is still a great keeper and will come good.

 

Come good? Hes 34ish now isnt he?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest toonlass

Harper has made some cracking saves, but I agree that at times he seems hesitant and then looks a bit panicky when he has decided what he is going to do. Despite that though I think he is still a great keeper and will come good.

 

Come good? Hes 34ish now isnt he?

 

And he is only just first choice keeper. I think he's rusty rather than anything else. At 34 he has still got 4-5 years left in him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest BooBoo

We can't simply play him on the basis that he hung around in Given's shadow for so long and so deserves his chance. That was his choice. Fact is, he's not up to scratch and is costing us goals. Now is not the time to lob in youngsters like Krul and Forster but i would be looking to start one next season or failing that, bringing in someone else to don the gloves.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Phil K

Not the keeper he was when he actually kept Given out of the team for a while.

I always thought he was very unlucky.

Sadly, I reluctantly agree maybe we'd be better off long term with Krul and have a fresh start with a lot of the kids instead of a pack of overpaid, sulking "stars" who aren't putting in the effort needed.

We're doomed anyways, thanks to no tactics coming out from where they SHOULD be coming from.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Harper has made some cracking saves, but I agree that at times he seems hesitant and then looks a bit panicky when he has decided what he is going to do. Despite that though I think he is still a great keeper and will come good.

 

Wouldn't you look "a bit panicky" with that defence in front of you?!

 

As someone else said Harper's the least of our worries, I think he's more than up to the job.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Its football not ever keeper is going to stop every shot, yeah okay Given was better but he left and wanted to leave so fk him, Harper is here and has been loyal to us, give the lad a chance to find his feet and gain more match fitness and sharpness.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

are some ppl on here goalkeeper experts, bar 1-2 keepers in the world would of saved that 3rd goal it was hit with precision and speed that he could hardly get down before it was past him

Link to post
Share on other sites

are some ppl on here goalkeeper experts, bar 1-2 keepers in the world would of saved that 3rd goal it was hit with precision and speed that he could hardly get down before it was past him

 

Due to poor positioning.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

are some ppl on here goalkeeper experts, bar 1-2 keepers in the world would of saved that 3rd goal it was hit with precision and speed that he could hardly get down before it was past him

 

Due to poor positioning.

 

notice how only newcastle fan's have picked up on it, there are some really fickle fan's on this board

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Howaythetoon

Some of his shot stopping reactions yesterday were first clash but as Tooj says he seems sluggish and several times he failed to communicate with Colo and Bassong to leave the ball as it was going through to him. His kicking is extremely poor too, as is his decision making when kicking. That said, he is the least of our problems and a more than good enough custodian in goal.

Link to post
Share on other sites

are some ppl on here goalkeeper experts, bar 1-2 keepers in the world would of saved that 3rd goal it was hit with precision and speed that he could hardly get down before it was past him

 

Due to poor positioning.

 

notice how only newcastle fan's have picked up on it, there are some really fickle fan's on this board

 

Why would fans of other clubs be looking and trying to analyze our performance to the same detail as Newcastle fans?

 

http://img4.imageshack.us/img4/6105/harper.jpg

 

Too big a gap at his near post imo, but just because I'm pointing out an error it doesn't mean I'm fickle, I've also mentioned he made some very good saves yesterday.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Howaythetoon

are some ppl on here goalkeeper experts, bar 1-2 keepers in the world would of saved that 3rd goal it was hit with precision and speed that he could hardly get down before it was past him

 

Due to poor positioning.

 

notice how only newcastle fan's have picked up on it, there are some really fickle fan's on this board

 

Why would fans of other clubs be looking and trying to analyze our performance to the same detail as Newcastle fans?

 

http://img4.imageshack.us/img4/6105/harper.jpg

 

Too big a gap at his near post imo, but just because I'm pointing out an error it doesn't mean I'm fickle, I've also mentioned he made some very good saves yesterday.

 

The rule of thumb with 'keepers is "can you cover it"? Harper did have it covered but failed to react quickly enough, that was his error, not his positioning.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...