Jump to content

West Ham Utd vs Newcastle United Pre-match thread 23/10/10 5:30pm *Live on Sky*


joeyt

Recommended Posts

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson  Campbell   Colo    Enrique

 

                             Tiote

               Barton

Guthrie                                 Jonas

 

               Ameobi   Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Tall Striker

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson  Campbell   Colo    Enrique

 

                             Tiote

               Barton

Guthrie                                 Jonas

 

               Ameobi   Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

 

Do you? You've named the same midfield as Saturday.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson  Campbell   Colo    Enrique

 

                             Tiote

               Barton

Guthrie                                 Jonas

 

               Ameobi   Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

 

Do you? You've named the same midfield as Saturday.

 

I tell you what lets drop the whole team. So Guthrie was to blame for the performance on saturday? Fuck off man.

Link to post
Share on other sites

                        Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo  Enrique

 

        Barton      Tiote      Nolan

 

Ranger                                    Jonas

                      Ameobi

 

 

This will definitely work.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Krul

 

Simpson Campbell Colo Enrique

 

Tiote

Barton

Guthrie Jonas

 

Ameobi Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

 

Do you? You've named the same midfield as Saturday.

 

I tell you what lets drop the whole team. So Guthrie was to blame for the performance on saturday? Fuck off man.

 

He didn't say that did he? He just said it didn't work, and it didn't. Guthrie was off the pace and congested the central midfield, whilst leaving our worst player horribly exposed. Simpson might cope better but he'll be rusty too.

Link to post
Share on other sites

                         Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

         Barton       Tiote      Nolan

 

Ranger                                    Jonas

                       Ameobi

 

 

This will definitely work.

 

 

 

I actually think it would.

Link to post
Share on other sites

                         Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

         Barton       Tiote      Nolan

 

Ranger                                    Jonas

                       Ameobi

 

 

This will definitely work.

 

 

Guthrie in for Nolan and i agree.

Link to post
Share on other sites

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson  Campbell   Colo    Enrique

 

                             Tiote

               Barton

Guthrie                                 Jonas

 

               Ameobi   Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

 

Do you? You've named the same midfield as Saturday.

 

I tell you what lets drop the whole team. So Guthrie was to blame for the performance on saturday? Fuck off man.

 

He didn't say that did he? He just said it didn't work, and it didn't. Guthrie was off the pace and congested the central midfield, whilst leaving our worst player horribly exposed. Simpson might cope better but he'll be rusty too.

 

He also didn't answer my question on the difference between home and away games or are we ignoring that the impetus at home is different that of away games. The same team could perform differently in one environment to another.

 

You say yourself that Guthrie congested the midfield, this is why i would play him, even if we lose a little of attacking flair (in which Routledge hasn't offered so far).

 

I agree Perch is shit, that's why i wouldn't play him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Tall Striker

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson  Campbell   Colo    Enrique

 

                             Tiote

               Barton

Guthrie                                 Jonas

 

               Ameobi   Carroll

 

Aye, because Guthrie on the wing worked really well on Saturday.

 

Do you know there is a difference between home and away games? Probably not.

 

Do you? You've named the same midfield as Saturday.

 

I tell you what lets drop the whole team. So Guthrie was to blame for the performance on saturday? f*** off man.

 

Where did I say he was? Why the need to tell me to 'fuck off man'?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Tall Striker

                         Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

         Barton       Tiote      Nolan

 

Ranger                                    Jonas

                       Ameobi

 

 

This will definitely work.

 

 

Guthrie in for Nolan and i agree.

 

We'd be more likely to go for:

 

                         Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

               Barton       Tiote

 

Ranger             Nolan                    Jonas

                     

                      Ameobi

 

 

 

 

which after 5 minutes of pressure on us would become

 

                             Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

Ranger  Barton   Tiote   Nolan Jonas

                       Ameobi

 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

                         Krul

 

Simpson      Campbell  Colo   Enrique

 

         Barton       Tiote      Nolan

 

Ranger                                    Jonas

                       Ameobi

 

 

This will definitely work.

 

 

 

I actually think it would.

 

I quite like the idea of Ranger on the wing, put him up against a fullback like Illunga and he'll have a field day in the air with the crossfield diagnal (Enrique, Barton).

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Tall Striker

Everyone is wanting to drop Williamson, quite disappointed it's such a widespread view.

 

More of giving Campbell his chance I think.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Everyone is wanting to drop Williamson, quite disappointed it's such a widespread view.

 

More of giving Campbell his chance I think.

 

Quite like Williamson, has done well so far - would rather keep him in over Sol until he does something worthy to give Sol a chance.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He didn't say that did he? He just said it didn't work, and it didn't. Guthrie was off the pace and congested the central midfield, whilst leaving our worst player horribly exposed. Simpson might cope better but he'll be rusty too.

 

Simpson was slaughtered more often than not last season for being a poor defender in the Championship, not that I agreed as he had no protection in front of him, Perch has had the same problem so far.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am unconvinced that Ranger is a better choice than Routeledge. As has been mentioned before: this switch seems to be overly optimistic.

 

I'm unconvinced too, but as I've had pretty conclusive proof that Routledge has lost all confidence (if he had any to begin with), I can't see how Ranger could be any worse. At the very least, he'll win something in the air and provide some extra height at set-pieces.

 

Routledge has been a complete non-event.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest BlacknWhiteArmy

I am unconvinced that Ranger is a better choice than Routeledge. As has been mentioned before: this switch seems to be overly optimistic.

 

I'm unconvinced too, but as I've had pretty conclusive proof that Routledge has lost all confidence (if he had any to begin with), I can't see how Ranger could be any worse. At the very least, he'll win something in the air and provide some extra height at set-pieces.

 

Routledge has been a complete non-event.

 

Ranger also gives away the ball in dangerous areas playing out wide, and is sloppy in possession, based on the Chelsea game.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...