manchester united

[KennyUtd]

2 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

He's tidy as fuck. We love him. The goals will come. 

Just don't see it with this lad. Would be nice if he even looked like he gives a shit. Newcastle must be pinching themselves that the stars aligned and they ended up with Woltemade.

From Red Cafe apparently. Not everyone agrees Froggy.

[Lazarus]

[ianbeany]

3 minutes ago, KennyUtd said:

Just don't see it with this lad. Would be nice if he even looked like he gives a shit. Newcastle must be pinching themselves that the stars aligned and they ended up with Woltemade.

From Red Cafe apparently. Not everyone agrees Froggy.

 

That was one of the kinder comments too.

 

 

"Absolutely woeful. Baffling how he wasn't subbed off. Clumsy, awful first touch. Literally did nothing good the whole game. So frustrating. Zirkzee is twice the player he is."

 

"He was awful against Nottingham Forest. His movement, his touches and physicality was worse than any Hojlund performances. He should not be our starting striker."

 

 

Edited November 1, 2025 by ianbeany

[KennyUtd]

Just now, ianbeany said:

 

That was one of the kinder comments too.

 

 

"Absolutely woeful. Baffling how he wasn't subbed off. Clumsy, awful first touch. Literally did nothing good the whole game. So frustrating. Zirkzee is twice the player he is."

Wow, that's damning like. 😄

[gbandit]

Don’t think I’d call him tidy. He seems quite messy to me in all honesty. Think he’s a physical lad who can put himself about and he’s got a rasp of a shot if he catches it well. He’s good in the air. Apart from that, I think he’s very unreliable with his feet, clumsy at times and can easily go missing for huge parts of games 

[KennyUtd]

Just now, gbandit said:

Don’t think I’d call him tidy. He seems quite messy to me in all honesty. Think he’s a physical lad who can put himself about and he’s got a rasp of a shot if he catches it well. He’s good in the air. Apart from that, I think he’s very unreliable with his feet, clumsy at times and can easily go missing for huge parts of games 

He's no better than Højlund like. Possibly less of a threat. It might come but he looks out of his depth currently. 

[Jewel]

5 minutes ago, ianbeany said:

 

That was one of the kinder comments too.

 

 

"Absolutely woeful. Baffling how he wasn't subbed off. Clumsy, awful first touch. Literally did nothing good the whole game. So frustrating. Zirkzee is twice the player he is."

 

"He was awful against Nottingham Forest. His movement, his touches and physicality was worse than any Hojlund performances. He should not be our starting striker."

 

 

 

So that's another highly-rated young talent ruined by Manure.

 

No sympathy for Sesko, though. He made his choice, he knew what he was signing up for.

[Conjo]

25 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

He's tidy as fuck. We love him. The goals will come. 

 

Think so too, in about 1.5 years when he's loaned out to a top half team in Italy or Spain. Nice of you to love him though.

[Froggy]

Don't know how many times I've told you lads to lay off the RedCafe.

[KennyUtd]

Just now, Froggy said:

Don't know how many times I've told you lads to lay off the RedCafe.

As soon as you lay off the crack. 😉

[Froggy]

16 minutes ago, gbandit said:

Don’t think I’d call him tidy. He seems quite messy to me in all honesty. Think he’s a physical lad who can put himself about and he’s got a rasp of a shot if he catches it well. He’s good in the air. Apart from that, I think he’s very unreliable with his feet, clumsy at times and can easily go missing for huge parts of games 

 

He has absolutely brilliant feet. And his link up play is top class. 

 

He was poor enough second half today, but been excellent lately. He's very important to how the team plays. 

[Froggy]

1 minute ago, KennyUtd said:

As soon as you lay off the crack. 😉

 

RedCafe is a shocking place. The same lads criticising him would have been praising him last few games. 

 

They'd have also been Amorim in, Amorim out, Amorim shake it all abouters too. 

[KennyUtd]

Just now, Froggy said:

 

RedCafe is a shocking place. The same lads criticising him would have been praising him last few games. 

 

They'd have also been Amorim in, Amorim out, Amorim shake it all abouters too. 

Ha that's every fans forum in the world eh. 

[Erikse]

31 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

He's tidy as fuck. We love him. The goals will come. 

 

Just like Hojlund was the best thing ever, and needed patience.

[Froggy]

Just now, KennyUtd said:

Ha that's every fans forum in the world eh. 

 

Aye 100%.

 

Seen a few lads laying into Amorim again and they're the same lads who were saying he'd turned it around last week. 

[Conjo]

Lets be honest - the praise is for him doing the bare minimum you'd expect from a striker in the PL. Like a young Newcastle version of Chris Wood.

[gbandit]

3 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

He has absolutely brilliant feet. And his link up play is top class. 

 

He was poor enough second half today, but been excellent lately. He's very important to how the team plays. 

Think his link up play is decent, he does look for teammates and has good understanding. Don’t think his feet are brilliant at all, he may develop into the player people hope he will but I watched him a lot after we were first linked with him and I thought he was overrated a lot. I haven’t watched more than two of his games with you so can’t really comment on his game at Amorim’s Emos 

[Kid Icarus]

4 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

RedCafe is a shocking place. The same lads criticising him would have been praising him last few games. 

 

They'd have also been Amorim in, Amorim out, Amorim shake it all abouters too. 

Where should we be looking for authentic Man United supporters opinions? Aside from other clubs' forums that is.

[Froggy]

5 minutes ago, Erikse said:

 

Just like Hojlund was the best thing ever, and needed patience.

 

I do think Hojlund has the ability to be a class striker. Still stand by that. 

 

 

Edited November 1, 2025 by Froggy

[Froggy]

Just now, Kid Icarus said:

Where should we be looking for authentic Man United supporters opinions? Aside from other clubs' forums that is.

 

Well is Newcastle Online a safe place for authentic Newcastle opinions?

 

I'd say just ask me for authentic opinions and you'll be safe. 

[Hovagod]

12 minutes ago, Froggy said:

Don't know how many times I've told you lads to lay off the RedCafe.

In which case, who’s ‘we’? Your fellow match going fans?

[Kid Icarus]

Just now, Froggy said:

 

Well is Newcastle Online a safe place for authentic Newcastle opinions?

 

I'd say just ask me for authentic opinions and you'll be safe. 

I'd say N-O's a pretty good barometer in the majority tbf.

 

You and Ronaldo often talk about how fans view this that and the other at Man United, but it's still a mystery who these people are.

[Erikse]

3 minutes ago, Froggy said:

 

I do think Hojlund has the ability to be a class striker. Still stand by that. 

 

 

 

 

How about Ugarte, you still think he's class and an absolute beast? Doesn't seem to be rated by Amorim these days.

[Froggy]

13 minutes ago, Kid Icarus said:

I'd say N-O's a pretty good barometer in the majority tbf.

 

You and Ronaldo often talk about how fans view this that and the other at Man United, but it's still a mystery who these people are.

 

I'm sure will Ronaldo will say his contacts in Manchester and his wife's family who are all season ticket holders. 

 

I'm going based on conversations I've had with people across multiple supporters clubs on match days. 

 

Last game I was at was Sunderland, just off the back of an awful result against Brentford and the support throughout the whole day was overwhelmingly positive for Amorim, but if you looked at RedCafe you'd think the entire fanbase hated him. 

 

We can try and pretend like half this forum didn't want Howe out if you want as well. Like 70% of it doesn't think Elanga is shit. Half of it probably thinks Woltemade is better than Isak now. 

 

Online fans are a different weapon entirely.  

[Froggy]

18 minutes ago, Erikse said:

How about Ugarte, you still think he's class and an absolute beast? Doesn't seem to be rated by Amorim these days.

 

Wouldnt say he isn't rated, but he doesn't suit the system like the others and Casemiro to Ugarte is a clear drop off. 

 

You can put this down to Ugarte being shit, or you can realise that Casemiro has been brilliant.