Mr Logic Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 The incoming players since last season. Who do you think will have the most Short Term Impact, STI. Who has the greatest long term future, LTF. Who has the potential to excite us the most, ala Beardsley, Ben Arfa etc., Exc. Scores should be out of 10, all 6/7, 3/4 and WNB's will be ignored. <5 Not so much; 5-6 Average; >6 Good; 9-10 I'm on Acid! [u]Matz Sels[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Matt Ritchie[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Dwight Gayle[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Jesus Gamez[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Isaac Hayden[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Grant Hanley[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Ciaran Clark[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Mohamed Diame[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]DeAndre Yedlin[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Daryl Murphy[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Achraf Lazaar[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] [u]Christian Atsu[/u] - [b]STI:[/b] [b]LTF:[/b] [b]Exc:[/b] (Copy paste the quote for simplicity?) OK, here we go. Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 7 Exc: 5 Matt Ritchie - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc: 8 Dwight Gayle - STI: 8 LTF: 7 Exc: 8 Jesus Gamez - STI: 6 LTF: 4 Exc: 4 Isaac Hayden - STI: 6 LTF: 9 Exc: 7 Grant Hanley - STI: 6 LTF: 5 Exc: 5 Ciaran Clark - STI: 4 LTF: 5 Exc: 4 Mohamed Diame - STI: 7 LTF: 6 Exc: 8 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 6 LTF: 7 Exc: 7 Daryl Murphy - STI: 6 LTF: 1 Exc: 5 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 8 LTF: 9 Exc: 9 Christian Atsu - STI: 6 LTF: 7 Exc: 7 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sima Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Jack Colback STI: All terminal. Hopefully. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ronaldo Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 9s for Lazaar? What don't I know about him that you do? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
loki679 Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 5 Exc: 5 Matt Ritchie - STI: 9 LTF: 9 Exc: 9 Dwight Gayle - STI: 7 LTF: 5 Exc: 6 Jesus Gamez - STI: 4 LTF: 3 Exc: 3 Isaac Hayden - STI: 8 LTF: 10 Exc: 10 Grant Hanley - STI: 5 LTF: 5 Exc: 4 Ciaran Clark - STI: 5 LTF: 2 Exc: 2 Mohamed Diame - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc: 6 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 7 LTF: 7 Exc: 7 Daryl Murphy - STI: 2 LTF: 0 Exc: :partridge: Achraf Lazaar - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc: 9 Christian Atsu - STI: 7 LTF: 9 Exc: 8 Did it wrong. The Exc is how excited I am about the signing. The other way is stupid anyway. Who gets excited by goalkeepers ffs. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr Logic Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 9s for Lazaar? What don't I know about him that you do? Probably nothing, I guess the second two is more to do with expectations than based on any facts. I just yearn for that kind of player and think he has the potential. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr Logic Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 5 Exc: 5 Matt Ritchie - STI: 9 LTF: 9 Exc: 9 Dwight Gayle - STI: 7 LTF: 5 Exc: 6 Jesus Gamez - STI: 4 LTF: 3 Exc: 3 Isaac Hayden - STI: 8 LTF: 10 Exc: 10 Grant Hanley - STI: 5 LTF: 5 Exc: 4 Ciaran Clark - STI: 5 LTF: 2 Exc: 2 Mohamed Diame - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc: 6 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 7 LTF: 7 Exc: 7 Daryl Murphy - STI: 2 LTF: 0 Exc: :partridge: Achraf Lazaar - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc: 9 Christian Atsu - STI: 7 LTF: 9 Exc: 8 Did it wrong. The Exc is how excited I am about the signing. The other way is stupid anyway. Who gets excited by goalkeepers ffs. Thank you Loki, that's the spirit. I'll get round to doing running totals if there's enough like that. (Though I'd appreciate less zero's if that were the case. ) edit: And yes, the last one is purely subjective, and attackers will obviously feature at the expense of the rest. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nattfare Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Jack Colback STI: All terminal. Hopefully. If getting hit by a truck; Exc: 10 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
TRon Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Don't want to go through all those players and form a mini table on a Saturday night, but I think there are a few obvious short term buys like Murphy, Gamez, Hanley and Clark, although the last two are young enough to maybe surprise a few people if Rafa sees something in them we don't. I think for exciting prospects, you could include Lazaar, Atsu and Yedlin. Long term, probably Ritchie, Hayden and maybe Sels funnily enough. Gayle could probably fit into all three categories tbh. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Altamullan Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 6 Exc: 5 Matt Ritchie - STI: 8 LTF:7 Exc: 8 Dwight Gayle - STI: 7 LTF: 7 Exc: 6 Jesus Gamez - STI: 4 LTF: 5 Exc: 6 Isaac Hayden - STI: 7 LTF: 9 Exc: 7 Grant Hanley - STI: 5 LTF: 6 Exc: 4 Ciaran Clark - STI: 4 LTF: 5 Exc: 4 Mohamed Diame - STI: 7 LTF: 6 Exc: 7 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 5 LTF: 6 Exc: 6 Daryl Murphy - STI: 6 LTF: 5 Exc: 6 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 5 LTF: 6 Exc: 7 Christian Atsu - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc:6 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
54 Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 8 Exc: 4 Matt Ritchie - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc: 9 Dwight Gayle - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc:9 Jesus Gamez - STI: 7 LTF: 4 Exc:4 Isaac Hayden - STI: 6 LTF: 8 Exc:6 Grant Hanley - STI: 6 LTF: 4 Exc:3 Ciaran Clark - STI: 6 LTF: 4 Exc:3 Mohamed Diame - STI: 7 LTF: 7 Exc:7 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 6 LTF: 7 Exc:6 Daryl Murphy - STI: 5 LTF:2 Exc:5 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 5 LTF: 7 Exc:7 Christian Atsu - STI:7 LTF:0 Exc:8 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kaizero Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 Use [ code ] content [ /code ] without the spaces for simplicity next time Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 5 Exc: 2 Matt Ritchie - STI: 8 LTF: 8 Exc: 6 Dwight Gayle - STI: 7 LTF: 4 Exc: 4 Jesus Gamez - STI: 3 LTF: 1 Exc: 2 Isaac Hayden - STI: 4 LTF: 8 Exc: 6 Grant Hanley - STI: 2 LTF: 2 Exc: 1 Ciaran Clark - STI: 2 LTF: 1 Exc: 1 Mohamed Diame - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc: 6 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 4 LTF: 5 Exc: 4 Daryl Murphy - STI: 1 LTF: 1 Exc: 1 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 4 LTF: 8 Exc: 8 Christian Atsu - STI: 4 LTF: 4 Exc: 4 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr Logic Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 Running totals to date: 5 results (bold red 40 or more) Matz Sels - STI: 25 LTF: 31 Exc: 21 Matt Ritchie - STI: 41 LTF: 40 Exc: 40 Dwight Gayle - STI: 37 LTF: 31 Exc: 33 Jesus Gamez - STI: 24 LTF: 17 Exc: 19 Isaac Hayden - STI: 31 LTF: 44 Exc: 36 Grant Hanley - STI: 24 LTF: 22 Exc: 17 Ciaran Clark - STI: 23 LTF: 17 Exc: 14 Mohamed Diame - STI: 33 LTF: 31 Exc: 34 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 28 LTF: 32 Exc: 30 Daryl Murphy - STI: 20 LTF: 9 Exc: 17 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 30 LTF: 38 Exc: 40 Christian Atsu - STI: 30 LTF: 26 Exc: 33 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
relámpago blanco Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 Why do most people think Lazaar will have a poor short term impact. He'll be replacing dumbest who is fairly shite. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tiotes Witch Doctor Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yorkie Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 Doubt Lazaar is here to be first choice tbh, same for Yedlin. Not that we'll have many 'first choice's this season under Rafa. He's going to rotate every game I imagine. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Collage Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 This Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
madras Posted September 4, 2016 Share Posted September 4, 2016 Doubt Lazaar is here to be first choice tbh, same for Yedlin. Not that we'll have many 'first choice's this season under Rafa. He's going to rotate every game I imagine. They could be but not at the same time. Rafa will only play one attacking full back at a time unless we are chasing a game. We actaully have a decent set up to go 3 at the back and wing backs. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
xLiaaamx Posted September 6, 2016 Share Posted September 6, 2016 Doubt Lazaar is here to be first choice tbh, same for Yedlin. Not that we'll have many 'first choice's this season under Rafa. He's going to rotate every game I imagine. They could be but not at the same time. Rafa will only play one attacking full back at a time unless we are chasing a game. We actaully have a decent set up to go 3 at the back and wing backs. That'll only be worth it if Ritchie can play behind two strikers Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sho Time Posted September 6, 2016 Share Posted September 6, 2016 Matz Sels - STI: 5 LTF: 7 Exc: 4 Matt Ritchie - STI: 10 LTF: 10 Exc: 9 Dwight Gayle - STI: 9 LTF: 8 Exc: 8 Jesus Gamez - STI: 3 LTF: 2 Exc: 3 Isaac Hayden - STI: 6 LTF: 7 Exc: 6 Grant Hanley - STI: 3 LTF: 3 Exc: 1 Ciaran Clark - STI: 4 LTF: 4 Exc: 1 Mohamed Diame - STI: 9 LTF: 7 Exc: 7 DeAndre Yedlin - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc: 6 Daryl Murphy - STI: 3 LTF: 1 Exc: 1 Achraf Lazaar - STI: 6 LTF: 6 Exc: 7 Christian Atsu - STI: 5 LTF: 3 Exc: 4 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now