Jump to content

NUFC Transfer Rumours


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Cronky said:

 

Way off thread topic, but I can't resist.

 

As I recall, Batty replaced Lee Clark in the anchor role, which at first I think was an upgrade, but maybe not a significant one. In later seasons, I think the conservatism of his play held us back a bit.

 

I think that the signing we shouldn't have made was Asprilla. Good player, but the partnership between Ferdinand and Beardsley, which was so fruitful, was disrupted, with Beardsley moving out wider to replace Gillespie, who was struggling. No-one would argue that Gillespie was a better player than Asprilla, but the shape and balance of the side was badly affected.

 

At time time of Asprilla's signing, Brian Clough wrote an article in a paper. He said that when Forest were closing in on the title, he was tempted to make a signing 'just to make sure', as it were. He resisted the temptation, thinking that the signing might be a vote of no confidence in the existing players, and was based on anxiety rather than positive thinking. Clough thought that the Asprilla signing would prove to be an error, for those reasons.

 

Right or wrong, you can't get any better than correctly predicting the outcome.

 

 

I'd largely agree with that. I always look at Asprilla coming in as the turning point. Cult figure and great player, but we didn't need a maverick striker, we needed to keep clean sheets and let our existing strikers do what they did best.

 

I watched something recently where one of the 1996 Liverpool players was discussing the 4-3 and they said that it was drilled in to them that Newcastle's fragility at the back meant we were very beatable. Especially once pressure began to build.

 

The PTSD from 1996 is still so strong. I was 18, going out on the hoy, doing plenty of skuttling, driving a car, looking forward to moving to a new city for Uni.

 

In principle life was class.

 

But I was devasted inside, emotionally traumatised by our capitulation. And being at school with a few glory seeking Tyne Valley Man Utd fans was the shitty icing on a dog turd cake.

 

 

 

Edited by bobbydazzla

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Cronky said:

 

Way off thread topic, but I can't resist.

 

As I recall, Batty replaced Lee Clark in the anchor role, which at first I think was an upgrade, but maybe not a significant one. In later seasons, I think the conservatism of his play held us back a bit.

 

I think that the signing we shouldn't have made was Asprilla. Good player, but the partnership between Ferdinand and Beardsley, which was so fruitful, was disrupted, with Beardsley moving out wider to replace Gillespie, who was struggling. No-one would argue that Gillespie was a better player than Asprilla, but the shape and balance of the side was badly affected.

 

At time time of Asprilla's signing, Brian Clough wrote an article in a paper. He said that when Forest were closing in on the title, he was tempted to make a signing 'just to make sure', as it were. He resisted the temptation, thinking that the signing might be a vote of no confidence in the existing players, and was based on anxiety rather than positive thinking. Clough thought that the Asprilla signing would prove to be an error, for those reasons.

 

Right or wrong, you can't get any better than correctly predicting the outcome.

 

 

I always felt that was a convenient excuse used to deflect the blame from some of the players who had got us firing in the first half of the season. Players like Ferdinand and Rob Lee just stopped scoring, and felt to me that in some of the big games on the run in we froze. If anything Tino was one of those who didn't seem affected by nerves, his goal to put us in the lead in the 4-3 Anfield classic a prime exampe. You can't really blame the chaos at the back on him.

Link to post
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, Coffee_Johnny said:

Does sound like someone we’d pursue. Fits the profile we tend to go for. 

 

Very strong rumours regarding him last summer from our side.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, SUPERTOON said:

 

 

If we still like him, and that's the price, I'd be very surprised if it doesn't happen.

 

Would likely then come down to the player's interest and demands.

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, jack j said:

Not seen much of Thiaw.

Robin Koch ahead of him in the Germany squad :whistle:

 

More of a younger talent with some decent experience at a top club, rather than a finished article.

 

With all the PSR palava, I think we'll probably see more signings in this mould, that can be got for decent fees and who are on lower wages.

 

Just had a look and Thiaw is on less than £20,000 a week at Milan.

Link to post
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, Keegans Export said:

Gonna be a great "Here's what you could have won" when we win the 2028 Champions League against Milan with Botman and this guy at CB.

Aye, like Milan will be there.:coolsmiley:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Couple of days without euro and copa America games. Was expecting more bullshit rumours to be knocking around this morning

Link to post
Share on other sites

Wonder if we want Thiaw so Howe can switch between Hall/Thiaw starting full backs and Kelly/Tino starting so he always has his three at the back

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Nucasol said:

Natch. I was at school down there in Long Eaton at the time so had the scabs giving it large the next day. Hated the cunts since, the ones that were actually Forest fans and not the subhuman plastics supporting Man Utd or Liverpool.

I know that school I think. Same one Michelle Yeoh the Chinese actress’ daughter went to. I used to work in long Eaton too. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Looking through tweets on him, Milan fans say that Thiaw is as slow as a snail, but that Kev Kawson said he'd have registered as the 8th fastest player in the prem based on his top speed last year

 

So no middle ground then it appears! 

Link to post
Share on other sites

If Italian fans are saying someone is slow that’s a bit concerning, especially with Botman already being of the snail persuasion. Do they mean he’s slow mentally?

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, bobbydazzla said:

 

 

I'd largely agree with that. I always look at Asprilla coming in as the turning point. Cult figure and great player, but we didn't need a maverick striker, we needed to keep clean sheets and let our existing strikers do what they did best.

 

I watched something recently where one of the 1996 Liverpool players was discussing the 4-3 and they said that it was drilled in to them that Newcastle's fragility at the back meant we were very beatable. Especially once pressure began to build.

 

The PTSD from 1996 is still so strong. I was 18, going out on the hoy, doing plenty of skuttling, driving a car, looking forward to moving to a new city for Uni.

 

In principle life was class.

 

But I was devasted inside, emotionally traumatised by our capitulation. And being at school with a few glory seeking Tyne Valley Man Utd fans was the shitty icing on a dog turd cake.

 

 

 

 

 

Feel almost the same and this is one of my criticisms of Keegan. Not exactly that he bought Asprilla, but that he always tried to shoehorn players into the side rather than pick the best players for the positions in his chosen formation. Something that I've noticed about successive England managers since the 90's too.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...