Quite frankly, I think that is a ridiculous argument. Spurs haven't beaten Liverpool, manure or Chelsea either, does that mean Martin Jol can't give Spurs a chance of competing with the best? Of course it doesn't, nor can that argument be levelled at Glenn Roeder either.
What makes you think he hasn't got the attributes to get Newcastle to the CL? He got the spanners to 7th in the premiership with practically no transfer money at all. One thing is for certain. If he doesn't get the top job, there will be plenty of clubs who have seen what he can do and will. I don't think you will see Roeder back in the Academy, time for something better, either at Newcastle or elsewhere.
He also took the same, very talented, team down the next season. Speaking to my WHam mate recently I commented on what a good job Roeder has done for us - he said the same thing of their first non-full season with him. The next season, according to him, they were dreadful. I believe Roeder has done exceptionally well for us as caretaker manager, but that's all it should be in my opinion.
Your mate must be one of the blinkered ones that think's the sun shines out of Terry Brown's *rse!!
When the spanners best two strikers at that time (Di Canio and Kanoute) were both out for 6 months and Brown refused to sanction the purchase or loan of a replacement, relegation was inevitable in most people's opinions. Maybe the only surprising thing was that they managed to go over 40 pts before being relgated.
Most fairminded spanners fans will admit that relegation was not Roeder's fault, it was all down to Brown's stupidity. Even FFS wouldn't leave his team with no strikers at all!
I take your point about their strikers, not least given they were playing Ian Pearce up front in that period.
I'll grant that the West Ham support isn't the most fair-minded in the world, but most of them don't seem to have a high opinion of Roeder, in my experience. I don't exactly spend much time around them, so I might just be hearing the loud-mouthed ones/Cockney journalists, mind.