Nobody

So Carr is good enough? No, he is not. But he is not as bad as you lot say he is. I would be very happy to have Carr as our back-up RB after Luke Young. Yet you say Milner is the reason the whole team are playing bad.... blueconfused.gif I did also say that that statement was an exaggeration. About the Carr not being good enough, that is for a side that should be around 5-6 in the table. For a 8-10, he is good enough, but that's not where we want to be.

I reckoned I was quite close. Dyer for Shola was the first one to be shown, 4 minutes from my prediction

I'd love to see Emre and Dyer in midfield, but I still don't want to leave Parker out and I'm not a fan of 4-5-1. Thought Emre had an ok game today, got better when Dyer came on.

It is not the managers fault that he cannot cross.

Did you see him playing for villa last year? he didnt take a free kick today. I did see him play for Villa last year. Never rated him that highly then, thought he looked decent, but nothing more. I know he didn't take a free kick, but he was still there and wanted to take them.

So Carr is good enough? No, he is not. But he is not as bad as you lot say he is. I would be very happy to have Carr as our back-up RB after Luke Young.

Milner is the fucking reason the team is underperforming. Okay, a bit harsh, but Milners way of playing is not affected by what the rest of the team is doing. He still only knows how to do one thing: run and then put a terrible cross in. Why does he think that he should take corners and freekicks?

Still think he is. Had a very, very poor game today though. The one claiming he is the worst one to have ever played more than 30 games in newcastle is the biggest moron alive. What you say is what you are.[/childish retort] Seriously though, you must be seriously deluded to seriously think that Carr is alright. He has never had a good game for Newcastle in the Premiership. He is slow, badly positioned, energyless, awful at marking, heading and dedfending set-pieces. Name a player to have played thirty games for Newcastle (post 1996) that has been worse. Shola, Bramble, Boumsong, Millner, As for Milner, he's been excellent. Given that you can't even spell Milner, I'm very sceptical about you knowing ANYTHING about Newcastle United. Spot on... :roll:

Still think he is. Had a very, very poor game today though. The one claiming he is the worst one to have ever played more than 30 games in newcastle is the biggest moron alive. What you say is what you are.[/childish retort] Seriously though, you must be seriously deluded to seriously think that Carr is alright. He has never had a good game for Newcastle in the Premiership. He is slow, badly positioned, energyless, awful at marking, heading and dedfending set-pieces. Name a player to have played thirty games for Newcastle (post 1996) that has been worse. Shola, Bramble, Boumsong, Millner, babayaro, ramage. edit: just realised that all of thse may not have started 30 games, but still played enough to be proven shite and way worse than carr.

Still think he is. Had a very, very poor game today though. The one claiming he is the worst one to have ever played more than 30 games in newcastle is the biggest moron alive.

Dyer for Shola after 60.

home or away?

Roeder wants to get the sack

Rossi is NOT on the bench.

Nothing but midfielders and a goalkeeper on the bench. And our starting strikeforce isn't really worrying, is it? I think I'm gonna be sick!

team please?

Got a call up for the game against holland next week. http://www.nufc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10278~926408,00.html

Tbf, there aren't many games I haven't seen this season. 7 games are usually on live every week plus one or two who are shown afterwards and if you still haven't seen it, there is still a chance to catch a torrent of it.

He'd be a giant if he came here

No. Carr has been very good this year and I don't see who else would be LB if not baba. Millner is f*cking shite and shouldn't be near our first XI and Solano lacks pace and haven't looked himself since he got back from his injury. So you don't go to the matches then. No. Your point being? Fucking hell, people like you make me sick, tbh. I see (almost) as many games as you do and fuck off with that you don't see them properly on the tv. And Millner is SHIT. The only man he can deliver the ball to is to their first defender.

No. Carr has been very good this year and I don't see who else would be LB if not baba. Millner is f*cking shite and shouldn't be near our first XI and Solano lacks pace and haven't looked himself since he got back from his injury.

Given Carr Moore Taylor Babayaro N'Zogbia Parker Emre Duff Martins Rossi Bench: Harper, Ramage, Solano, Luque, Sibiersky

newcastle - southend chelsea - liverpool spurs -arsenal charlton - wycombe draw wycombe in the semi-finals agree that everton are the biggest scumbags in the league, especially that f**k cahill

even no one of them are good goalscorers, they're pace and movement will be needed. Great News!

of course its about opinions, i must be the only one here that thinks carr has been one of our best players this season