Yep - I would say that Nolan was a fair bit more overweight than HBA.
I'd also say that Nolan's weight issues were often discussed and criticised on here.
That's not my point - my point is whether Nolan was fined by the club for it and it was used as a reason not to pick him. The answer to that is that it wasn't.
That was my point as well. It never seemed to be an issue with the club although the fans regularly discussed it (as do West Ham fans).
Nolan, as much as I was never much of a fan, has a much bigger frame naturally than Hatem. He was captain, leading goalscorer for most of his time here and basically ran the first team prior to Pardew coming in.