It's very difficult for any of us to reel in the hatred we've had for him in an Everton shirt and that is bound to cloud some judgement, whenever he's played against us he's been a nuisance, at 22 he's still raw and probably not had much in the way of coaching in a tumultuous few seasons at a struggling Everton. Having said that this does seem a somewhat underwhelming prospect in line with some of the names mentioned. I'm on the fence, but if our recruitment team see something in him I'll give him the benefit of the doubt until he proves otherwise.