Harper 7 - fine, a few good stops too
Simpson 5.5 - kept backing off again and also was nowhere to be found during many Villa attacks
Williamson 7 - not at fault
S. Taylor 4 - lost Collins for the goal and was his general clumsy, superman self. also lucky not to see a pen awarded against him
Enrique 5 - piss poor, kept losing the ball and generally an off touch
Barton 5 - please just shut the fuck up and play the game, poor set pieces
Guthrie 4 - passing rotten, invisible after the hour mark
Coloccini 5 - out of position and it showed. fine at centre back after switch over
Gutierrez 5.5 - final ball lacking once again
Ranger 4 - absolutely terrible, has no idea how to hold the ball up
Lovenkrands 4 - a few half-chances and one he should have scored. otherwise anonymous in play
SUBS:
R.Taylor 5 - one excellent cross and one wasted late set-piece
Kuqi 6 - not enough time, a marginal improvement on our other forwards however