Jump to content

Cf

Claudia Winkleman
  • Posts

    5,846
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Cf

  1. Yeah. But also our injury list is ridiculous. Anyone but city would be struggling with this. We've had Ritchie on most of the game FFS.
  2. Cf

    England

    I mean if you're gonna take Trippier and Wilson from us just take Livramento and Gordon instead surely? The former two are running on fumes plain as day. Give the young un's a run out. I still maintain from a footballing perspective Southgate has achieved the bare minimum acceptable level. Taken into account the wealth of talent available and the very favourable fixtures I don't think he's been impressive at all and we've generally failed the first time we've faced decent opposition.
  3. Often the difference between a dive and falling over is the player turning around and claiming a penalty, or how they fall, etc. Body language can give a lot away. For those looking for a foul or initiate contact incidents there's not necessarily punishment required but if the sentence "he was looking for that" is in any way applicable then benefit of doubt to the defender. I'm not saying every instance needs punishment, nor that every foul that's not means deception has taken place. Just that if referees were more proactive with it, and that reds were available for the most egregious examples, it would soon stop. And we accept that there's situations where refs would get it wrong. The same they do for anything else on the pitch.
  4. I feel similar really. Something off about entering it as losers of the proper thing.
  5. Argh. That needed to be back across. He went for the wrong header.
  6. I've been impressed with Lascelles but 90% of his passes are to Schar whilst missing someone else that's open.
  7. An interesting take I read that I agree with is as much as we complain about VAR one of the issues we have is players trying to deceive refs. And I agree with that and maybe it should be the next clampdown. Some easy fixes: Make simulation red cardable, and be much more willing to yellow card when you suspect simulation. Sterling I think it was last night should easily have been booked for trying to buy a penalty (Check complete - on field decision stands - no penalty - suggest booking for simulation). Blatant cases where they're looking for the foul and contact isn't even made should be a red with a 3 match suspension. Going down clutching your face such as when Bruno made contact with the chest and the various other flavours of going down theatrically should be punishable by a yellow too. Would we end up with a few yellows that possibly aren't? Sure, but we get that for legitimate tackles anyway. And the number would reduce when players realised what was happening and they stop doing it. The games the game and players try to take what edge they can. I get that. But the above examples are going into cheating territory for me and for all the talk of improving the standards of officiating we could start with improving the standards of playing.
  8. Given the clampdown on players showing dissent this year (which I agree with but it could still be handled better) they really need to apply the same attitude to managers and clubs. You should be able to express disagreements and grievances, but Arteta, Arsenal, and even Liverpool should be facing punishment. The statements from both clubs are worthy of sporting sanctions to me. We're trying to set a better example of players respecting referees etc but here's two examples of at the very top clubs not doing the same.
  9. If anything spurs just drawing attention to how to play against them here. This ridiculous high line isn't due to being at 9.
  10. Does their goalkeeper have to go off for 30 seconds because he's received treatment?
  11. Chelsea not even taking corners now. Just holding on against 9 men.
  12. This is awful by Chelsea. Should be getting double digits here the way Spurs are playing.
  13. I wonder how sky's graphic copes with more than 3 reds.
  14. I always feel sympathy and think it should be somehow taken into account when a mistimed tackle is a result of a bad pass from the other team.
  15. In the sense of "this is how we can improve as a team" sure you can. We become one of the top teams by learning from those errors and not making them again.
  16. It was 50/50 to me. Joelinton has a right to go in for the header but the defender is weak and is going to ground without Joelinton's help in a misjudged header. But then Joelinton does help him on his way, partly because of the position the defender put himself in. Wouldn't be arguing too strongly if it was given as a foul but given its arguable either way just give the benefit of the doubt.
×
×
  • Create New...