Jump to content

Cf

Claudia Winkleman
  • Posts

    5,846
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Cf

  1. Could Mbappe not just have chosen to score there? Why the theatrics?
  2. But what if that free kick or corner leads to a goal? Think there was a case in the world cup where France dived, got a free kick, scored from it and won. That's a pretty big moment. The more you use it for the more tempted you are to use it for something else.
  3. Hall's yellow against Dortmund was really soft and imo not even a foul. He had to play on eggshells from then on. Should VAR be intervening in every yellow card decision? I get your point about potentially reviewing the 2nd yellow could prevent some red cards that aren't but where do you stop? Tweet above suggested reviewing corner kick decisions. Do we just review decisions every time the referee blows his whistle? I'm being facetious to a point but this is where it leads.
  4. But what's the criteria for overturning a 2nd yellow? If the 2nd is not a foul? So a clear and obvious mistake? What if the 2nd is a clear yellow but the first wasn't even a foul? No yellow for the 2nd offence that was a yellow? What if the 2nd is a bit soft and the 1st was a bit soft? Do they cancel out? And how long do we spend reviewing to work out if it was soft or not? Just keep this shite away from the game imo.
  5. Just looked at the Fulham penalties. Jesus christ. WTF is VAR playing at? First one clearly wasn't a penalty yet VAR sticks with on-field decision and the second the attacker throws himself into the defender and VAR intervenes to award the penalty. Ludicrous.
  6. I think clubs are maybe starting to wise up to the fact that changing managers isn't the silver bullet they think it is and possibly to an extent it once was. You can't just get in a relegation specialist anymore. See Leeds last season. And promoted teams these days need to expect there's a good chance they're going straight back down as they don't have the resources to compete. Instead you might need to go down with a view to coming back up and having a better shot at it next time. Boils down to do you think you have the right man or not. If so stick with him.
  7. How whether our ball was in play or not vs arsenal was decided in a matter of seconds? How whether it came off Joelinton or not and when the contact was made in determining an offside or not was made in a matter of seconds? That one incident had an example of whether the ball was in or not and who touched it last take a couple of minutes to decide. We don't want to open corners to that sort of thing.
  8. How's it good in the long run? It sounds awful. We already lose so much time to this nonsense. Last thing we need is more of it. It's the slippery slope you start going down though when you allow the use of replays in refereeing.
  9. https://understat.com/league/EPL We're 2nd in xPTS. Man Utd are 11th
  10. Cf

    Tino Livramento

    Still can't believe Southgate took a run into the ground Trippier for two exhibition matches over Livramento. Should have been sacked on the spot for that.
  11. Man Utd have scored 16 goals in 13 games. How the fuck are they on 24 points. Come on.
  12. Those cynical fouls people do to stop a break and then block the free kick? Yellow for the foul + yellow for the block = red.
  13. Don't commit fouls and give away free kicks then?
  14. Cf

    England

    Howe might be available soon.
  15. Cf

    England

    And the Maguire one. God he's shit
  16. Cf

    England

    Pahahaha just seen the penalty. Wtf.
  17. Cf

    Eddie Howe

    Think this is the main takeaway I got from the Netflix PR piece. Most of it was super scripted but the way she referred to Eddie all the time felt natural. She clearly has a massive amount of respect for him.
  18. Cf

    Eddie Howe

    This is all some elaborately made up ruse, surely? Hangxiety? Completely made up. The planting of a MEN article to sell it was a nice touch. Real dedication to the bit.
  19. It's the fact they spent a minute reviewing the footage. And clear and obvious being so subjective. Don't get me wrong I'd happily bin the whole thing.
  20. I guess the issue is that by the time you've spent a minute reviewing the footage you want the right decision to be made irrespective of what the on field call was. In this instance wouldn't take much for the VAR to just go "bit soft this one, they've got hold of each other and Haaland pulls him to get in front in the first place. Go and have a quick look to see if you want to stick to your decision or not".
  21. They're fucked though. Fatigue affects you mentally as well as physically. Joelinton after injury was obviously not fully match fit yet has been playing non stop since. We desperately need this break.
×
×
  • Create New...