WilliamPS

Be surprised if Shelvey moves in January, would expect his focus to be on getting the games to trigger his extension. plus hardly well stocked in CM and he’s capable of doing a job there every so often

Bloke has barely played since September yet in the view of some in here he’s gone from the second best player in the squad to a no hoper in that time. When exactly did he become lazy? The attack is very flat with Almiron, Joelinton, Willock and Longstaff. with Bruno out the team will need a bit of creativity. Joelinton and Almiron are industrious triers but they are not creative And if ASM goes, he will need to be replaced in the squad with someone with similar attributes - dribbling, pace, ability to beat a man, as nobody else has that. And all this track back stuff - have you considered for a second if he is asked to play a different role to Joelinton or Willock as he has different skills? I.E. stay high up the pitch as an outlet I’m quite happy with the team as-is, but can’t stand the desperate need to hound players out of the club for imaginary wrongdoings

A standing area would be great - and based on the away experience it does help the atmosphere. Personally I prefer to stand at matches anyway However if you’re standing in a seating section of course you are going to get told to sit down - for a start not everyone sat behind can stand up for 90 mins so you’re ruining their view

I like Klopp but I think we’re close to the time he quits for a break. Liverpool still have a class squad and have been v unlucky with injuries but feels like the squad also need a change at the top, 8 years is a pretty long tenure these days

Shocking form people booking travel for thE final already Dont jinx this!

In years gone by I think it’s been season ticket holders who attended the cup games first, as the allocation is large enough they points become less relevant - but this is all 20 years out of date!

Not sure a CB will be priority when 2 have already been bought in the lat year and the midfield and forward line is desperately thin - not saying it wouldn’t be good, but if there’s a 100m to spend is that where it would go? Difficult RB seems to be a bit more of a priority due to Trippier needing cover.

Be disappointed if he is on the way out as he’s the most exciting player to watch - football is entertainment and he brings that. So I hope it’s all bollocks Am utterly bemused by the fans who prefer to see Joelinton start at left forward than ASM (much as I like Joelinton) and I hope if he does leave he’s replaced by someone with a bit of flair

Probably as most fans recognise he’s one of the best attackers at the club and they enjoy watching him play?

We don’t even know if 433 in the permanent approach or if it’s just what’s best with the available squad we might see a dm brought in then both a new dm and Bruno forming a two in midfield to let the front 4 be more positive IMO moving Joelinton back into midfield and playing an attacker who carries a bigger threat at left forward is essential to improving the attacking play. Look at ASM vs Man City. Injuries have left the attack looking pretty flat last few games

My issue with a lot of these rumours is whenever a player is missing a load of social media attention seekers spot an opportunity to make up a story. ASM is a big player for Newcastle so they can’t resist. They have zero knowledge or insight It might be true - but like the transfer rumours these people post a load of shite and every so often a story is right just by chance. meanwhile a load of fans go off on one

Some over reaction about the performances of some of the players. If you drop must of them into the first 11 they’ll do ok. Making 8 changes in one go, when most of those players have barely played this season is going to have a negative impact on the team performance, you don’t have any of the little partnerships or relationships on the pitch. Newcastle dominated the game, and if not for some poor finishing would have been easy winners.

Always been an element in the fan base who seem desperate for certain players to fail. Same thing on the Dubravka thread. Totally crackers

Won’t build a top 4 squad without offering European football to incoming players. And to not get Europe means finishing 7th, which will also mean 6 PL clubs have a better offer to players The quicker the better as far as Europe is concerned. I now doubt it’ll be CL but leapfrogging the Europa conference would be v helpful in terms of incoming transfer

Given the current options off the bench I’d keep him and play him, rather than having various knackers kick lumps out of him in the SPL. If you’re good enough you’re old enough loans make sense if you aren’t getting game time, but would that be the case?

The media know Newcastle are interested in fresneda as they know the scouts were there - beyond that it’s guesswork Maybe the scout report came back negative. Might be scouting ahead of a summer bid. Or he’s on the plane A first team backup for Trippier feels smart as if there’s a European campaign you’d think it would be too many games for Trippier next year. However it’s not an immediate issue so it wouldn’t be a big shock if it was left to the summer

If you had a really defensive DM a la Declan Roce type you could have a much more attacking LB though, so it’s a question of balance in the side

100% this. He can now sign a pre contract agreement with foreign clubs, in 6 months he can move for free to a PL club - consciously or unconsciously he will be holding back as a big injury would be disastrous for him personally. It will get worse as the season goes on. Having a player who wants to leave enter the last 12 months of his contract carries this risk (if the player is desperate to stay it’s totally different). Leicester should really try and move him on now.

Arsenal are a better side, at home and in great form - so expectations have to be set accordingly. However I don’t agree with the suggestion Newcastle should be passive and worry about Saka etc - if you try and contain a team like Arsenal the likelihood is they take an opportunity and win. You have to do play your best team and try and cause the opposition problems. For me, that means starting ASM and having him stay high up the pitch. Give White a decision to make about going forward, give Arsenal a constant headache about leaving ASM one on one with a defender - as against Man City. That means Joelinton, Burn and Botman have to be on it when Arsenal attack down the right, but you have to trust players

Not sure where this anti Dubs stuff has came from - he’s a good goalkeeper, way better than Karius and club needs two decent keepers. Darlow is a liability. Dubs has never let the club down and course was going to be frustrated at Pope coming in Welcome back! I’d start him in the FA Cup game at least

Philips is currently being Pep’d. He was used to a certain standard at Leeds and now is having to adapt to Man City’s higher level. Grealish had the same last season. Philips will either emerge a much better player or if he fails to make the grade be cast off.

Don’t think it’s ever ‘too early’ for CL, you get bags of cash, play against the elite teams, attract the best players and also deny the opportunity to another English club

Howe stuck with the winning team from Leicester yesterday but now time to play the best 11 - ASM and Wilson in. I’d take out Wood and Willock, leave Longstaff and Joelinton in for their energy and workload in midfield. Willock off the bench after 60, a role he is very effective at.

Shows the value of goal scorers - lack of fitness for ASM and Wilson (and perhaps Isak) costing 2 points today A lot of the other players will chip in with a few here and there - which is v important - but regularly scoring in the PL is a skill and to win week in week out you need your goal scorers on the pitch

Every opposition manager will get asked that q or a similar one and many will give a more hostile answer than that one And of course it’s the money - last season relegation was nailed on. No takeover cash = no Howe and no signings. It’s not just the money spent, it’s the promise of much more cash to come as well, so historic net spend isn’t so relevant. No way Botman, Bruno and Isak sign, and Howe/Ashworth etc commit unless they believe the spending is going to run and run. Personally I’m happy with that, but I totally get why other clubs will massively resent it.