Jump to content

Hertha Berlin 1 - 0 Newcastle - 01/08/08 - post match reaction from page 17


Recommended Posts

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor     Enrique

                         Butt

Milner                Guthrie                 Duff

           Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest ObaStar

Didn't Owen say he would be ready for that tournament? Slash Keegan is definitely not giving Barton 10 mins. he got out of prison like yesterday. Owen had the mumps at teh beginning of June and still isnt playing matches

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Didn't Owen say he would be ready for that tournament? Slash Keegan is definitely not giving Barton 10 mins. he got out of prison like yesterday. Owen had the mumps at teh beginning of June and still isnt playing matches

 

 

Yes but since he said he would be ready, we have been told he will not be.

Link to post
Share on other sites

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor     Enrique

                         Butt

Milner                Guthrie                 Duff

           Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

 

I've got some sort of image in my head of him being a defensive, deep-lying playmaker, just from some of the comments off here (i've seen neither friendly). Purely just from what i've read of his alleged spreading of play/ball retention skills, etc. Am i wide of the mark with that assumption, anyone?

Link to post
Share on other sites

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor     Enrique

                         Butt

Milner                Guthrie                 Duff

           Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

 

I've got some sort of image in my head of him being a defensive, deep-lying playmaker, just from some of the comments off here (i've seen neither friendly). Purely just from what i've read of his alleged spreading of play/ball retention skills, etc. Am i wide of the mark with that assumption, anyone?

 

 

Aye, fuck off back to York

Link to post
Share on other sites

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor    Enrique

                        Butt

Milner                Guthrie                Duff

          Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

 

I've got some sort of image in my head of him being a defensive, deep-lying playmaker, just from some of the comments off here (i've seen neither friendly). Purely just from what i've read of his alleged spreading of play/ball retention skills, etc. Am i wide of the mark with that assumption, anyone?

 

Almost as wide as James' head tbf.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest Coubury

I want to see Bassong start.

 

And Jonas and Guthrie

 

Wonder how long Oba will be away for hope its not long (i know that sounds bad lol)

Link to post
Share on other sites

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor     Enrique

                         Butt

Milner                Guthrie                 Duff

           Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

 

I've got some sort of image in my head of him being a defensive, deep-lying playmaker, just from some of the comments off here (i've seen neither friendly). Purely just from what i've read of his alleged spreading of play/ball retention skills, etc. Am i wide of the mark with that assumption, anyone?

 

 

Aye, fuck off back to York

 

:lol: Random. Though technically i never left. :shifty:

Link to post
Share on other sites

any idea of the squad we've sent/sending. people are nominating what they see as the strongest 11 out of the available resources. i'd give at least a couple of the kids, lua lua,carroll,edgar,tozer,donninger ,forster ,kadar,zamblera etc  a full game, 2 each,in each game /9if they travel that is)                   

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest kevarmy

any idea of the squad we've sent/sending. people are nominating what they see as the strongest 11 out of the available resources. i'd give at least a couple of the kids, lua lua,carroll,edgar,tozer,donninger ,forster ,kadar,zamblera etc  a full game, 2 each,in each game /9if they travel that is)                     

 

really think we should play strongest available 11,really dont want to go to OT on the back of a few heavy defeats.

Link to post
Share on other sites

any idea of the squad we've sent/sending. people are nominating what they see as the strongest 11 out of the available resources. i'd give at least a couple of the kids, lua lua,carroll,edgar,tozer,donninger ,forster ,kadar,zamblera etc  a full game, 2 each,in each game /9if they travel that is)                   

 

really think we should play strongest available 11,really dont want to go to OT on the back of a few heavy defeats.

the players wont even be bothered about results. just sharpening up physically and using the ball in match situations. also a chance for the manager to try out stuff. ie formations and testing players under certain situations.
Link to post
Share on other sites

                              Given

Beye      Faye                  Taylor     Enrique

                         Butt

Milner                Guthrie                 Duff

           Jonas

                                    Smith

 

Is Guthrie a playmaker? (serious question)

No Iw ould just play him as a traditional box to box cm with Butt holding.  Theres enough creativity on the wings to dispense with a playmaker plus we don't have one anyway.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest loonietoonie

That doesn't make sense. You cant judge what level we are at when we arnt at full strength correct?

Link to post
Share on other sites

That doesn't make sense. You cant judge what level we are at when we arnt at full strength correct?

 

Of course we can

 

Ok the Strikers maybe missing but you can still gage how well the defensive shape is and the style and formation we're likely to use through the middle

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

does every1 else think once we get owen, martins and viduka back, then this team will start to look good, with another few signings

Link to post
Share on other sites

does every1 else think once we get owen, martins and viduka back, then this team will start to look good, with another few signings

 

Yes

 

We do need at least another 3 players not including Bassong and Coloccini if he comes.

 

Left Back, Right Back, And Attacking midfielder before i'd start to get too excited, But I Think our defense would be the strongest it has ever been in the premier league and a bit better going forward.

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

does every1 else think once we get owen, martins and viduka back, then this team will start to look good, with another few signings

 

Yes

 

We do need at least another 3 players not including Bassong and Coloccini if he comes.

 

Left Back, Right Back, And Attacking midfielder before i'd start to get too excited, But I Think our defense would be the strongest it has ever been in the premier league and a bit better going forward.

 

 

 

we don't need 5 defenders coming in, that would mean we have 5 CB's and 4 full backs, another 2 yes

 

we do need another CM though

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...