Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Guest malandro

Category One status is a must as well.

Category one status means f*** all if you have no one of any quality coming through your academy.

 

Carroll aside, we only have Campbell who looks anything sort of quality. Sammy has pace but no final ball, even against Everton his pace didn't seem to be enough. Ranger we bought and shows no promise, Bigi again was bought. Streete, well he's unknown, we all have high hopes for him but we have fallen for that a few times over the last few years.

Apart from having a wider catchment area, funding from the FA and (I think) the ability to poach players off clubs who don't have C1 status.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I went with 18 as a ball-park figure, you could argue you need more. Then you can have people out on loan, who could then maybe come back later on and offer legitimate depth if they develop with the gametime.

 

Mind, in my perfect world we'd also be playing good football and have a set style of play where young players could drop into without too much strain. Imagine that, ey.

 

You're critique of my post is spot on. I'm not saying those are the concrete lads that should have been kept, I'm saying those lads are decent squad players who if left, should have been replaced with well- what you mentioned in your post  you're post is fantastic. I just thought it needed to be said how poorly our board plans for squad depth, why was obvious to all of course.  :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

I went with 18 as a ball-park figure, you could argue you need more. Then you can have people out on loan, who could then maybe come back later on and offer legitimate depth if they develop with the gametime.

 

Mind, in my perfect world we'd also be playing good football and have a set style of play where young players could drop into without too much strain. Imagine that, ey.

 

You're critique of my post is spot on. I'm not saying those are the concrete lads that should have been kept, I'm saying those lads are decent squad players who if left, should have been replaced with well- what you mentioned in your post  you're post is fantastic. I just thought it needed to be said how poorly our board plans for squad depth, why was obvious to all of course.  :thup:

 

Our criticisms were the same in reality and I'm sure mirror most of the board's opinions. :thup:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to see an end to Ashley's spell at the club - would take very big bucks to get rid of him and I can't see any likely source of that.

 

The Qataris are our best hope but they will just wait until things are REALLY in a mess - like heading for relegation  - so they can screw Ashley for the best deal....in fact, we could be in the Championship before there is a change of owner.

 

This reminds me of when Villa had Doug Ellis and their fans were desperate to get rid of him but it took years...at least they got Lerner, we got rid of Shepherd and got Ashley...

 

The only decent thing he  has done is to take on the club's debt.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to see an end to Ashley's spell at the club - would take very big bucks to get rid of him and I can't see any likely source of that.

 

The Qataris are our best hope but they will just wait until things are REALLY in a mess - like heading for relegation  - so they can screw Ashley for the best deal....in fact, we could be in the Championship before there is a change of owner.

 

This reminds me of when Villa had Doug Ellis and their fans were desperate to get rid of him but it took years...at least they got Lerner, we got rid of Shepherd and got Ashley...

 

The only decent thing he  has done is to take on the club's debt.

 

Would you really want the club to be a foreign owners play-thing? Have them come in and spunk loads of money on random players leaving the club soulless and without any real tradition or respect like Man City or Chelsea? I'd rather keep grinding and earn any glory than have it drop into our lap like a lottery win.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hard to see an end to Ashley's spell at the club - would take very big bucks to get rid of him and I can't see any likely source of that.

 

The Qataris are our best hope but they will just wait until things are REALLY in a mess - like heading for relegation  - so they can screw Ashley for the best deal....in fact, we could be in the Championship before there is a change of owner.

 

This reminds me of when Villa had Doug Ellis and their fans were desperate to get rid of him but it took years...at least they got Lerner, we got rid of Shepherd and got Ashley...

 

The only decent thing he  has done is to take on the club's debt.

 

Would you really want the club to be a foreign owners play-thing? Have them come in and spunk loads of money on random players leaving the club soulless and without any real tradition or respect like Man City or Chelsea? I'd rather keep grinding and earn any glory than have it drop into our lap like a lottery win.

 

Would you really like to be taken for a fool every year by empty promises of new players to improve the side and then end up by selling more players than you sign and getting booted out of the FA Cup 2 years running by a seaside town team ?

 

If you would, good luck to you - I prefer a successful side with quality players and actually winning  a few trophies for a change. Maybe you don't want all those distractions of having to go to Semi-finals and finals...far better to sit at home and watch other teams doing it on TV ...?

 

Yes I WOULD rather we got taken over and did a Man City...is that clear enough ?

 

Incidentally - has anyone told you what the odds are on winning the lottery,...!?

Link to post
Share on other sites

New owners have generally been s*** across the board with the exceptions being when they have enough money to offset the fact that they know nothing about football - Chelsea and Man City.

 

Are you saying they are not partly to blame for the current situation ?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Keggie,

 

Yup, seems the dont want to listen to anyone in football but prefer to make their own mistakes despite the best advice they've had.

 

In 20 years time they'll know how to run the club  :lol: :lol:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...