Jump to content

Pixel Replay - Newcastle United Edition


geordie_b

Recommended Posts

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

Agree completely with Ian here. Could be the real "quirk" that always comes with successful marketing.

 

"Less is more" type of thing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

I disagree with this. These goals are memorable events and having the score and date provides context of the day. Makes it more memorable.

 

By the way if this hits big time, you might want to consider filing some sort of patent or intellectual property protection. Otherwise some fucker will just copy your idea.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

I disagree with this. These goals are memorable events and having the score and date provides context of the day. Makes it more memorable.

 

By the way if this hits big time, you might want to consider filing some sort of patent or intellectual property protection. Otherwise some f***er will just copy your idea.

 

The creation celebrates the goal though. That in itself is a memorable event. Some great or significant goals have been scored by teams who ended up on the losing end as well. Maybe PR can give you the choice of having the whole match commemorated.

 

Agree with the second part. Get on it pronto mate.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest icemanblue

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

Agree with this. It also makes the image a bit too 'busy'.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

Agree with this. It also makes the image a bit too 'busy'.

 

We have similar concerns and are looking at some alternatives. I like the original simplicity of the design and the concept that to the people it means something to they will know the score and scorer. I think there is a balance to be found and hopefully I'll find it...

 

By the way we will be randomly selecting a request from our Facbook page at 1pm so head over to Facebook.com/PixelReplay and get involved :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd love me a copy of the Van Basten winner against the USSR in '88.

 

When will you start taking orders in gb? What's your pricing like etc.?

 

Loving this thread at the moment  :smitten:

 

No idea yet I'm afraid, i'm exploring a number of options and they will dictate prices. To be honest I've been surprised by the response and it's caught me a little off guard, and I haven't even launched to concept to an audience wider than NO yet!

 

As soon as I have products/pricing in place I will be posting on here along with a special discount for NO users :)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest firetotheworks

It's an obvious one, but if you could do the Carlos Alberto goal against Italy without it looking like spaghetti junction ('hahahahahahahaha') then I think that would be excellent.

Link to post
Share on other sites

A couple of the running lines in the Asprilla goals seem to be the wrong way around?

 

Providing the rules are on the ball = dashes, off the ball = dots.

 

You're right, they were all over the place. It was late and I was knackered but they are fixed now

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it's a mistake to add the game and the scoreline, it was better with just the goalscorer and goal time. Then there's a bit of insider knowledge about them, you can see if people know where the goal is from, you can explain it to them etc.

 

I would keep it as simple as possible with the text.

 

I disagree with this. These goals are memorable events and having the score and date provides context of the day. Makes it more memorable.

 

By the way if this hits big time, you might want to consider filing some sort of patent or intellectual property protection. Otherwise some fucker will just copy your idea.

 

Great idea this, but might want to follow the advice in the above post as a priority. Also, since you're looking to commercialise this, you might want to check that you are not breaching someone else's IP. I know Codemasters had the Sensible Soccer brand, and I can't imagine they would be happy someone else making cash out of this. Having said that, they might have just bought the name rights, not whatever intellectual property exists in the original graphics for example. It would still rest with someone though, maybe Jon Hare and the original guys at Sensible.

 

It is not a foregone conclusion that they could prevent this (you are not after all releasing a computer game with the same graphics), but as soon as you start making money from something you will find that the owners of the IP will start taking a bit of interest in this. Might be worth just checking this point with someone before you spend a load of your own time and money on it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...