Newcastle United 3-0 Aston Villa - 26/12/24

[David Edgar]

1 minute ago, joeyt said:

 

How was the goal crazy?

 

Crazy good. 

 

My first post about the goal was just wow three times. But that doesn't fit the narrative you are trying so weirdly to keep spinning joey. Bless you.

[El Prontonise]

2 minutes ago, David Edgar said:

 

Not at all. You are being really weird now. Really weird.

 

 

 

[David Edgar]

3 minutes ago, El Prontonise said:

 

 

Feel like I'm being baited into getting banned. 

 

I've put my entire opinion about why I felt uncertain of the result before the red card only for it to be completely ignored and then have another wave of these super ignorant and super simplistic posts about me being so negative and wrong. I'm just using this space to express my opinion on the game. The weird lot are joey and co who are putting in more effort on me than the game, yet are wilfully ignorant of anything and everything I have posted that doesn't fit their weird campaigns. 

 

 

Edited December 27, 2024 by David Edgar

[Southern Geordie]

33 minutes ago, The Butcher said:

Wouldn't have complained too much if the ref had given him a yellow.

 

Reading on Villatalk and they call our players for cheats. Forgot to mention Rogers throwing himself to the ground, holding his face, when Joelinton just nicked him in the chest.

Brummie Mackems, always the victims and their players can do nothing wrong.

[Fak]

Chaps man, it’s Xmas. If you thought we pissed it from the first whistle to the last: that’s fine. If you thought we were getting dominated at some stage of the game and were worried we were gonna throw the game away: that’s fine. 
 

It’s a game of opinions, just let it go.  

[NE27]

Lads all need a few more pigs and blankets in their life, and a nice sloe gin.

 

 

Edited December 27, 2024 by NE27

[joeyt]

24 minutes ago, David Edgar said:

 

Feel like I'm being baited into getting banned. 

 

I've put my entire opinion about why I felt uncertain of the result before the red card only for it to be completely ignored and then have another wave of these super ignorant and super simplistic posts about me being so negative and wrong. I'm just using this space to express my opinion on the game. The weird lot are joey and co who are putting in more effort on me than the game, yet are wilfully ignorant of anything and everything I have posted that doesn't fit their weird campaigns. 

 

 

 

 

I think I'd speak for a few to say the only agenda and campaign involved here is from you and the negative posting. 

 

I'm sure you said "Kill iz" before a game recently that we won comfortably and saying that Tonali has saved Howe. It's just negativity for negativity sake and nothing constructive. Whenever we do well there always seems to be a caveat to your posts "Ipswich were shite", "Villa look more likely to win" etc

[David Edgar]

... and then have another wave of these super ignorant and super simplistic posts about me being so negative and wrong. 

[wormy]

I'd love to be vindicated in my opinion on that red by any appeal getting time added for frivolity. 

[BonesJones]

11 hours ago, wormy said:

 

Have you never played football, Bones? There was only ever going to be one place his foot ended up to avoid Schar decapitating his penis like the thug he is! 

 

I have played football, I was a left back. Opinion valid.

[toon25]

Just watching the highlights. Absolutely brilliant performance. The midfield 3 again showing that they've found their positions. Tonali everywhere. And Isak, man. Nothing short of world class. His ball control makes him a constant threat - defenders don't know what to do with him.

[Joe1984]

14 minutes ago, joeyt said:

 

I think I'd speak for a few to say the only agenda and campaign involved here is from you and the negative posting. 

 

I'm sure you said "Kill iz" before a game recently that we won comfortably and saying that Tonali has saved Howe. It's just negativity for negativity sake and nothing constructive. Whenever we do well there always seems to be a caveat to your posts "Ipswich were shite", "Villa look more likely to win" etc

In defense of David I'd just like to point out 1 thing...

 

Ipswich WERE shite... 😄

[NSG]

57 minutes ago, Hanshithispantz said:

What is the actual rule?

 

That's never a penalty at the other end. Accidental handballs with your arm by our side will be disallowed if it goes straight in, but will stand if it was going wide and was deflected in?

Yeah so basically if it had been Bruno’s goal, it would have been disallowed and fair enough. But because the deflection off Bruno was going wide and it hit the defender then technically it’s an own goal (if it was going in it would have been Bruno’s goal and rightfully disallowed).

 

Theres no way there is any way they could have checked that because it was an instantaneous decision, it took me a good few replays to find one to confirm it was going wide.

[wormy]

6 minutes ago, BonesJones said:

 

I have played football, I was a left back. Opinion valid.

 

Aye prolly left back in the dressing room!!! Am I right!!!

[Shearergol]

2 hours ago, Lush Vlad said:

He was very unfortunate. He tried to miss him on 3 separate occasions by moving his legs in Schar’s direction.  

I had to swerve numerous times before mowing down the cyclist, officer.

[astraguy]

Are they appealing it? Thought it would of broke by now considering they play Sunday 

[GeordieDazzler]

Not sure how they can appeal it, it’s not a clear and obvious error. In real time in the ground it looked nasty and intentional.
 

That’s what I saw and the ref saw. Intentional or not he’s stood on him twice VAR would only have taken action if he hadn’t. They aren’t there to debate intentionality, ref saw a player get stood on and he did. 

[Tsunami]

Why was Rogers given a free ride in the media for trying to get Joelinton sent off and McGinn immediately getting into Taylor’s ear for well over a minute? 

[huss9]

had never heard of morgan rogers prior to this season.

was he just as good at boro?

signing of the season?

[healthyaddiction]

1 minute ago, huss9 said:

had never heard of morgan rogers prior to this season.

was he just as good at boro?

signing of the season?

They bought him last season.

[LFEE]

1 minute ago, huss9 said:

had never heard of morgan rogers prior to this season.

was he just as good at boro?

signing of the season?

Was impressed with him. Great signing.

[huss9]

was relieved when they subbed him off.

if they'd managed to grab a goal, we would have shat ourselves.

i wasnt able to relax till our third.

PTSD.

[DahnSahf]

4 hours ago, Lush Vlad said:

He was very unfortunate. He tried to miss him on 3 separate occasions by moving his legs in Schar’s direction.  

 

Maybe he watches a lot of Indycar? They reckon you should aim for the car spinning ahead of you 'cause by the time you get there it'll be somewhere else.

[mikejaxer]

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/11661/13280444/ref-watch-aston-villas-jhon-duran-right-to-be-shown-red-card-vs-newcastle-says-dermot-gallagher

 

Correctly shown a red according to Ref Watch

[RodneyCisse]

I can’t believe how many think it was accidental (outside this forum) I was worried the ref would lose his bottle and not do the right thing.