Surely that's more down to the lack of talent in the academy, can't think of any that have "made it" at Newcastle, most will end up being sold/released because they are not good enough, this is a common problem at NUFC, our academy has been poor for the last decade.
Aarons is this years Adam Armstrong who was Adam Campbell the season before that, players that get a bit of hype, look ok in pre season but turn out to really not be as good as people think and drops off the radar.
Can't think of anyone who I'm confident will become a regular at Newcastle from the development squad.
The problem we have with Sammy Ameobi, Mehdi Abeid, Gael Bigirimana, Paul Dummett, Shane Ferguson & Haris Vuckic are that they are over 21 (i.e born after 1.1.93) so we have to register them in the 25 man squad to be able to play them in the Premier League, where previous seasons we didn't need too.
Considering we already have 23 players we have to register to play in the Premier League (6 of those are home grown from a possible 8) we can only register 2 from the above list of 6 and we can't actually add any foreign based players unless we sell another foreign based player first.
From the weekend game, Dummett started & Abeid was on the bench so looks like them two will fill the final spaces.
TLDR version - we are going to have to sell/loan Ameobi, Bigirimana, Ferguson & Vuckic or let them rot in the development squad all season with the odd cup game in the first team
Footballers don't improve in a non-competitive environment, and the Northumberland Senior Cup doesn't count. It's a vicious circle. Are the players not playing because they're not good enough or are they not good enough because they're not playing enough football? Probably a bit of both in there but it seems to me that during the absolutely critical stage of a footballer's development, late teens, most of our players seem to just rot in the reserves for years, either that or go on loan in League One and rarely see the field.
I know one thing, there were very few Newcastle fans who saw anything in Andy Carroll, even right up until around January of the Championship season. Then suddenly he scored a brace against WBA in the cup and he was off, unstoppable, from a value of next to nowt to £35m in the space of almost exactly 12 months. At that age, the potential effects of playing regular and competitive professional football cannot be understated.
I don't know the ins and outs of how these things are dealt with elsewhere in terms of picking the right places for players to go on loan, integrating them into the first team etc etc - but I do know we're not doing it properly. We just hoy them all on in the cup then blame them for going out and use it as an excuse not to play them again. I say 'we', I mean the cunt.
Going slightly off topic for a rant, for all the talk of HBA being mistreated, the way Bigirimana has been cast aside since being dragged off at half time against Benfica having been hung out to dry on the wing is one of the most pathetic and disgraceful things I've ever seen from NUFC. Absolutely shameful. Nobody will care when he ends up back at a lower level than we got him from, that's just football, nobody gives a shit about some kid who "didn't make it" but when possible, I'd like my football club to be respectful and professional, not just put human beings on the scrapheap because some arsehole window fitter gets a lip on (Ben Arfa), or because they were daft enough to link a contract extension to appearances (Jonas), or because the coaching staff are too fucking thick to know what to do with them (Bigi).