If Carroll is fit, he should start and Ranger should sit on the bench. He looked knackared after about 70 minutes today, what with him playing U19's games as well. Don't want the lad to suffer from burnout - best thing to be done with these young players is to dip them in and then dip them out again.
GK - Harper
RB - Simpson
CB - Coloccini
CB - S.Taylor
LB - Jose Enrique
RM - LuaLua
CM - Guthrie
CM - Barton
LM - R.Taylor
CF - Carroll
CF - Lovenkrands
is what I'd go for, but Butt will no doubt start and unfortunately Nolan too.