But the point is, was it a clear and obvious error? I don’t know if there’s a difference between that and ‘was it right or wrong’, that’s quite a difficult semantic question. But I guess there’s supposed to be.
When he looks at the screen, I guess he should ask ‘was it reasonable that I decided it wasn’t a penalty?’. He’s not meant to be redoing the decision as such.
I see your point actually. Although, for me, a ref going to a screen and potentially redoing the decision is the way to go. I’d take that over how VAR has previously been implemented.