Jump to content

Football's greatest - where does Lionel Messi rank?


Dave

Recommended Posts

By the same token it's a complete myth that this Argentina side is s****, well in terms of the players in the squad anyway.

 

On paper sure, but Aguero and Di Maria were injured and Higuain didn't show up.

 

It never really quite came together how we all imagined.

Link to post
Share on other sites

The year is 2014, not 1986. Football has evolved. To carry a team to a World Cup or a League title, like Maradona did, is simply not possible in today's game, IMO.

 

If we're talking semantics I'd argue that while it's near impossible to replicate something a la Napoli, with the WC it actually is viable. Since international football isn't (or at least not as directly) impacted by vast differences in resources - i.e. money - I think the notion of a player carrying a country to glory is a realistic one.

 

Whether it's more romantic than anything and Messi should be criticised for not being able to do is a different matter, as is whether it's all actually that important.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, is it just me or does Messi just look plain knackered?

 

Not one for hyperbole but when fit, he plays virtually every minute of every single game. Year after year. Especially under Guardiola, it felt like he never, ever got subbed. Add in international commitments too and you've got to wonder whether he's simply worn out and whether it's all catching up with his body a bit?

 

Whatever it is, he's not the same Messi of 2008-2013. Something's changed, just hope it's not permanent.

 

Stamina wise he looks f*cked, i don't think he's being lazy in particular just that he can't seem to relentlessly hound opposition defenses without the ball like he used to for what ever reason.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think he's being lazy either. Part of his 'style' is the fact he clearly conserves energy and deliberately walks around the pitch half the time.

 

I dunno. Something's missing. I'm not sure whether it's all physical either. I wonder if he's lost some of his spark, some of his real hunger. Hope I'm proved completely wrong and he's back to his best for Barca this year.

 

But, and I know he's set himself utterly ludicrous standards, I'm thinking for the first time that maybe, just maybe, we've already seen the best of Lionel Messi? :undecided:

Link to post
Share on other sites

So basically what you're saying is that the players that e can say played shite are the ones that you are deciding by some arbitrary rule? :lol:

 

They have a fair few brilliant players and most of them played well, hence how they almost won it.

The post I was quoting said they have some very good players on paper. I said that their best players on paper apart from Messi, Mascherano and Zabaleta were poor such as Aguero, Higuain and Di Maria. I agree that the likes of Garay, Rojo, Demichelis, Biglia etc. played well

Link to post
Share on other sites

How can you say Higuan especially is better than Garay?

 

Anyway it doesn't really matter, but Aguero was injured for half of it so it's slightly unfair to say his was poor, same with Di Maria who actually played well imo for at least 2 of the group games.

Link to post
Share on other sites

How can you say Higuan especially is better than Garay?

 

Anyway it doesn't really matter, but Aguero was injured for half of it so it's slightly unfair to say his was poor, same with Di Maria who actually played well imo for at least 2 of the group games.

I would have thought people would have rated Higuain above Garay before the tournament started, no? Higuain had the likes of Arsenal and Napoli battling for him last summer while Garay has gone to Russia this summer

Link to post
Share on other sites

How can you say Higuan especially is better than Garay?

 

Anyway it doesn't really matter, but Aguero was injured for half of it so it's slightly unfair to say his was poor, same with Di Maria who actually played well imo for at least 2 of the group games.

I would have thought people would have rated Higuain above Garay before the tournament started, no? Higuain had the likes of Arsenal and Napoli battling for him last summer while Garay has gone to Russia this summer

 

What's the point in this? Garay is a top class CB while Higuain is a top class ST.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Aguero might have a pass for the latter stages but he was really poor even in the group when he was supposedly fit for action, albeit after a season of niggles. I didn't see the Iran game but his performance against Bosnia was absolutely awful.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi looked tired throughout the entire of the season, imo, and is back playing high pressure football at the highest level in little more than a month. He has carried so much on him the last 6+ years. Fatigue is very natural.

How can you say Higuan especially is better than Garay?

 

Anyway it doesn't really matter, but Aguero was injured for half of it so it's slightly unfair to say his was poor, same with Di Maria who actually played well imo for at least 2 of the group games.

Their attacking players outside of Messi generally just did not perform well in this tournament at all, given the standard they set at the club level.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi been regularly sick on the pitch during matches tells you something up.

 

Shouldn't have taken his growth hormones. :yao:

 

On a serious note though, I do wonder what's wrong, it's not the first time either.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi is a great club player for Barca - he's in a top side - but for me he is just a turbo version of Peter Beardsley, who he slightly resembles.

Scores more goals than Beardsley did, but no way is he in the class of Pele, Maradona, Cruyff etc. Very good player at international level but not a genuine great for me....just to balance the books, I don't believe Neymar is either.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Also, is it just me or does Messi just look plain knackered?

 

Not one for hyperbole but when fit, he plays virtually every minute of every single game. Year after year. Especially under Guardiola, it felt like he never, ever got subbed. Add in international commitments too and you've got to wonder whether he's simply worn out and whether it's all catching up with his body a bit?

 

Whatever it is, he's not the same Messi of 2008-2013. Something's changed, just hope it's not permanent.

 

:thup: Genuinely think the Messi of two/three year ago would've won that tonight. Hopefully he just needs an extended break, but he doesn't look anywhere near his best at the minute.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi is a great club player for Barca - he's in a top side - but for me he is just a turbo version of Peter Beardsley, who he slightly resembles.

Scores more goals than Beardsley did, but no way is he in the class of Pele, Maradona, Cruyff etc. Very good player at international level but not a genuine great for me....just to balance the books, I don't believe Neymar is either.

 

To me there's no question about him being up there with those names (without never really seeing them play). Regardless of his WC showings so far and in the future.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He still has another try to emulate Maradona and his 86 campaign. This year he managed to at least get Maradona and his 90 campaign emulated. Very similar in comparison they are too. Both not at their best yet still somehow managing to carry Argentina to a final defeat against the Germans.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi is a great club player for Barca - he's in a top side - but for me he is just a turbo version of Peter Beardsley, who he slightly resembles.

Scores more goals than Beardsley did, but no way is he in the class of Pele, Maradona, Cruyff etc. Very good player at international level but not a genuine great for me....just to balance the books, I don't believe Neymar is either.

 

To me there's no question about him being up there with those names (without never really seeing them play). Regardless of his WC showings so far and in the future.

If you had seen them play, you would know what I mean....I stick by my view.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Messi is a great club player for Barca - he's in a top side - but for me he is just a turbo version of Peter Beardsley, who he slightly resembles.

Scores more goals than Beardsley did, but no way is he in the class of Pele, Maradona, Cruyff etc. Very good player at international level but not a genuine great for me....just to balance the books, I don't believe Neymar is either.

 

To me there's no question about him being up there with those names (without never really seeing them play). Regardless of his WC showings so far and in the future.

If you had seen them play, you would know what I mean....I stick by my view.

I agree. I would have him on Cruyff's level mind. But not as high as the two others . It's hardly criticism of Messi to say he's not quite as good as the best and second best of all time though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Cruyff didn't need to win a World Cup to generally be considered the 3rd greatest player of all time.  And neither does Messi to be listed with them.  They both came up against a fantastic German side, and couldn't quite get it over the line in the King's parlance (although the Netherlands really should have won it in 74).

 

In basketball, Charles Barkley never won an NBA championship, but he was without doubt one of the greatest players of all time.  Some people get so stuck on this silverware thing.  It takes more conditions to win, not the least of which is the team you go up against in the final. FFS, Inzaghi won the World Cup with Italy.  That's great in all for a forward who can barely walk four steps without falling down, but nobody on this side of sanity would put him in the same league with Messi.

 

Messi did not look himself throughout the World Cup.  Only glimpses.  I won't say he's the greatest ever, but I won't use winning a World Cup as my metric.  Messi, the dour little hunchback that he is, is still one of the greatest players I have ever seen.

Link to post
Share on other sites

^^^^

 

I agree with all of this, but you can't deny that the little fellow missed an opportunity to end this debate once and for all today. Losing in this final (and playing poorly by his standards) doesn't tarnish his legacy imo, but playing well and winning could have cemented it.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...