Jump to content

Newcastle United 1 - 0 Norwich - 18/3/12 - post-match reaction from page 35


Recommended Posts

Guest neesy111

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

This. If Ruddy doesn't make that save, Lots of people on here would say Cabaye had a decent game for that beautiful assist. Yes he's had better games for us, but today he was just necessarily solid and did his job.

I actually think Guthrie was poor, caught in possession a lot and wasteful.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Krul - 6

Simpson - 6

Jonas - 8

Coloccini - 7

Williamson - 5

Ben Arfa - 6

Guthrie - 6

Cabaye - 6

Perch - 8

Ba - 6

Cisse - 7

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

So frustrating the lack of movement when we have the ball. It's hardly a wonder we can't keep the ball.

 

It's ridiculous at times.  It's like soon as HBA get the ball, everyone just stops.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

 

Harsh on HBA yes as I thought he did give us a fair bit of impetus in the First Half. Guthrie was decent in fits and starts, but for a guy of decent build he gets knocked off the ball too easily.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

 

Harsh on HBA yes as I thought he did give us a fair bit of impetus in the First Half. Guthrie was decent in fits and starts, but for a guy of decent build he gets knocked off the ball too easily.

 

I just can't get away with how bad he is off the ball, it's where Cabaye excels in as his workrate off the ball is fantastic, Guthrie's for some reason is poor.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

 

Harsh on HBA yes as I thought he did give us a fair bit of impetus in the First Half. Guthrie was decent in fits and starts, but for a guy of decent build he gets knocked off the ball too easily.

 

I just can't get away with how bad he is off the ball, it's where Cabaye excels in as his workrate off the ball is fantastic, Guthrie's for some reason is poor.

 

His vision and ability to pick a pass is brilliant at times, but as you say he appears quite lazy off the ball. He is a decent squad player who I would keep hold of, but I would like some more depth at CM in the summer.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

Was he? Looked like a central midfield three to me.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

Was he? Looked like a central midfield three to me.

 

I'm pretty sure you're right considering Jonas was constantly moving up the left flank, even ahead of Cabaye at points.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hope Pardew took note that the possession for the goal was obtained from Ben Arfa robbing a Norwich player in our half.

 

Don't think he would have, he tackled a Norwich player, James Perch looked like Beckenbauer today

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

 

Harsh on HBA yes as I thought he did give us a fair bit of impetus in the First Half. Guthrie was decent in fits and starts, but for a guy of decent build he gets knocked off the ball too easily.

 

I just can't get away with how bad he is off the ball, it's where Cabaye excels in as his workrate off the ball is fantastic, Guthrie's for some reason is poor.

 

Yep. Off the ball he's horrendous.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He was supposed to be playing out wide and simply refused to. It was a very undisciplined performance by him.

 

He played very narrow but he and Gutierrez were at the hub of most of our attacks. They linked up well as a pair down that side.

 

1st Half.  We didn't do a single attack down the left hand side until the 75th minute 2nd half.

 

We were crap for a lot of the Second Half I'll agree. That's where I think Pardew's subs were smart, the introduction of Santon and Shola settled the side down.

 

The subs were right, tho I didn't agree with the HBA going off for Santon.  I would had took off Guthrie.

 

Harsh on HBA yes as I thought he did give us a fair bit of impetus in the First Half. Guthrie was decent in fits and starts, but for a guy of decent build he gets knocked off the ball too easily.

 

I just can't get away with how bad he is off the ball, it's where Cabaye excels in as his workrate off the ball is fantastic, Guthrie's for some reason is poor.

 

Yep. Off the ball he's horrendous.

 

no problem with his workrate, just dont think hes that good at finding space for himself

 

also seems to get drawn in too much, defensively he is constantly leaving gaps for opposition players to get inbetween our midfield and defence, i think its a simple case of not being able to read the game well enough to be as effective in that role as our first choice midfield pairing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...