Elliot Anderson (now playing for Nottingham Forest)

[Sibierski]

Anderson is either amazing or shit. Guys not played regular football above championship, so it’s a deal that’s worth making. Like we’re too blinkered or blinded by the FM world. Anderson may become an amazing Barkley talent where we’re ruing letting him going so cheap, or he doesn’t play at Forest and we’re laughing. 

 

How much did Everton get for Barkley?

[Ronaldo]

Had a good pre-season, some decent games in the league.

 

Don’t see loads of talent there if I’m being brutally honest, so not hugely fussed.

[Weezertron]

3 minutes ago, M1tche said:

Who of a similar level has gone for more money than the 2 we've agreed to sell?

 

If we had bought them for the prices agreed, would you be saying we've got a great deal?

 

 

 

I’d be chuffed with Anderson for the reported 10m. That’s nowt. And if we’re to believe Eddie, Anderson is a talent.

[Vinny Green Balls]

Some takes on here provide evidence that humans made a mistake crawling out of the trees.

[Conjo]

23 minutes ago, Yorkie said:

 

 meanwhile we've just made a £26m profit on a player who's never even been to St James'.

 

I suppose we should've just accepted whatever Chelsea offered for Isak. 

 

Such a dumb way to look at it.  Why does it matter whether he played for us or not? He was still our player and is one of the most highly rated players in his position in the world (backed up by his performance metrics in a league grossly underrated on here). We've sacrificed someone with a great potential for short term gain. Poor management. Can't really coat it any other way. Lets just hope this is the exception rather than the start of a new trend.

[Cf]

A shame it hasn't worked out for him here but over the last season or so I haven't seen anything that suggests he should be part of the team if we have towards the top of the league ambitions. 

[Sibierski]

I like Anderson, but with no Europe I’ve said for ages that with lack of games we either play him or he goes out on loan to see his level long term.

 

Here, we’ve got Forest paying £10m off the bat. Where his talent could be more Elanga v Reyna. Just a deal you have to accept when in reality it would’ve likely been a loan. 

[Chris L]

2 minutes ago, Conjo said:

 

Such a dumb way to look at it.  Why does it matter whether he played for us or not? He was still our player and is one of the most highly rated players in his position in the world (backed up by his performance metrics in a league grossly underrated on here). We've sacrificed someone with a great potential for short term gain. Poor management. Can't really coat it any other way. Lets just hope this is the exception rather than the start of a new trend.

what else would you have done differently financially? 
 

they had to bring in quality players, who cost more.. to gain ground on teams around us at the time. If they brought in lesser/cheaper players and not progressed. People would have been fuming at that instead. 
 

there are players here who have been here a while who they can’t sell as no one wants to buy. So not a huge amount of opportunities to bring money back in.  
 

it was obvious when he signed that players like minteh were potentially brought in with this sell on for higher amount idea in mind. Which has happened. Koul was another but that doesn’t seem to be working.  
 

this next 3 year cycle should be much better. They inherited a club that has had next to no revenue generated for a decade. They’ve built this up already. 

[KaKa]

5 minutes ago, Vinny Green Balls said:

Some takes on here provide evidence that humans made a mistake crawling out of the trees.

 

 

Do you think following American sports leagues, and all the salary cap drama, free agency and trades, helps make this all easier to grasp do you think?! I'm thinking it might do.

[aussiemag]

14 minutes ago, Shadow Puppets said:

It’s not financially irresponsible… it’s pushing things to the limits of the rules to allow yourself to compete, knowing full well (as Eales and co have told us), that to stay within rules you have to sell at some point.

yeh but you are limiting your selling capacity when you are in a state of desperation to meet financial requirements. Clubs will low ball you and you aren’t getting the maximum amount for your asset. 

[Bunk Moreland]

At his age he really needs to be playing regularly, which he wont get the opportunity to do here. Good luck to the lad.

 

Quite pleased we've managed to bridge our shortfall without doing those swap deals like the other clubs. Gives the cartel one less route to come at us from.

[M1tche]

6 minutes ago, Weezertron said:

I’d be chuffed with Anderson for the reported 10m. That’s nowt. And if we’re to believe Eddie, Anderson is a talent.

Chuffed with buying a 7th choice CM? That's had a few half decent games out of nearly 50 in the prem and got about 2 assists while supposedly being more of an attacking CM? that's just saying stuff to back up your original statement. 

 

Also care to answer the 1st question. Who of a similar level has gone for more?

[Weezertron]

1 minute ago, M1tche said:

Chuffed with buying a 7th choice CM? That's had a few half decent games out of nearly 50 in the prem and got about 2 assists while supposedly being more of an attacking CM? that's just saying stuff to back up your original statement. 

 

Also care to answer the 1st question. Who of a similar level has gone for more?

Yes, I like Anderson. I wanted to keep him. I don’t really know what else I need to say. 

[Super Duper Branko Strupar]

I think people are forgetting that we're going to be constantly buying and trying to bring up young talent. We've bought very highly rated Harrison who from all the noises about him should be pushing for the first team. Now this Pivas. Miley. We have to choose who we develop for the first team and who makes way to allow that to happen. You cant keep all the youngsters, we keep the best. We also want to buy to strengthen the first team so we're going to lose more than we keep.

I know selling good youngsters is an alien concept to us, but we should be happy we're doing that now. In the past they've languished in the reserves or out on loan forever, not good enough to play and not good enough for anyone to want to buy. We can reel off lists of "promising youngsters" that we got nothing from in terms of contribution or resale. We've pissed and moaned about not having an academy, when we get a good one good youngsters will leave, it's happened at good PL clubs for years. It's a positive its looking like its starting to happen to us. 

Mismanagement my arse. 

[Yorkie]

12 minutes ago, Conjo said:

 

Such a dumb way to look at it.  Why does it matter whether he played for us or not? He was still our player and is one of the most highly rated players in his position in the world (backed up by his performance metrics in a league grossly underrated on here). We've sacrificed someone with a great potential for short term gain. Poor management. Can't really coat it any other way. Lets just hope this is the exception rather than the start of a new trend.

 

We're at completely opposite ends of the spectrum on this that I don't think it's worth the debate. 

 

Personally, I'm incredibly relieved that - in response to an unfair rule designed to ruin us - we've managed to avoid being ruined. If that's poor management then I don't know what to say. 

[toon25]

14 minutes ago, Cf said:

A shame it hasn't worked out for him here but over the last season or so I haven't seen anything that suggests he should be part of the team if we have towards the top of the league ambitions. 

 

100% this.

 

I hate selling not-shit players to anyone, but that's the situation we're in at the moment. If we were under Ashley we'd be cashing in on Bruno and Isak.

[Terrymac1966]

So how much can we now spend is the pertinent question.

 

[Vinny Green Balls]

We have to sell everyone to spend. Something is amiss.

 

 

Edited June 29, 2024 by Vinny Green Balls

[Pilko]

A shame he's away, but I think it opens the path up for Miley a bit more who clearly has a much higher potential ceiling. The injury early last season definitely slowed his progress after that excellent pre-season and since then he's filled in and done a job rather than nailing down a place.

 

If this sale means we can flex our muscles and strengthen key positions then it's worthwhile, although obviously the PSR stuff stinks to high heaven and we should be able to do that anyway with him still on voyage if we wanted him to be.

 

Hope we get a good fee and that he can use the move to nail down a position and kick his career on at Forest. 

[Kimbo]

I think Anderson has talent but we can’t say he hasn’t had enough chances to make his mark here.

 

Hopefully this is the end of this PSR guff and we don’t end up in this position again. 

[Oregon_Geordie]

Agree with many on here. Not sure he was ever going to be a regular first team starter but very sad to see a local lad with obvious talent sold off cheaply without giving him more time. He would have been a dependable and positive squad player for a few seasons. Never let us down but maybe lacked the pace to really cut through. That aside, the last few days have been bleak in regards what the game represents now - it's a fucking sham and pretty depression the only way you can spend is by selling on your own young talent.

 

Rules made up by the few to suit the very few. The games going to shit.

 

 

Edited June 30, 2024 by Oregon_Geordie

[huss9]

14 minutes ago, Vinny Green Balls said:

We have to sell everyone to spend. Something is amiss.

 

 

 

aye. complete fuck up.

heads are gonna roll tomorrow (not literally).

dummet being brought back in to help pad out the squad.

[Ketsbaia]

Fine with this.

 

He's ok but ultimately our 7th CM. Would be slightly annoyed at £10m but the Minteh/Anderson combo sale is probably a win - despite the mental torture of today.

[vexred]

Sad to see him go. Hopefully this is the start of a big reshaping of the squad. If we can get rid of Longstaff, Almiron, Wilson, and Trippier, it’ll have been a successful summer.

[gazza ladra]

1 minute ago, vexred said:

Sad to see him go. Hopefully this is the start of a big reshaping of the squad. If we can get rid of Longstaff, Almiron, Wilson, and Trippier, it’ll have been a successful summer.

Well yes, if we buy upgrades on Longstaff, Almiron, and Wilson. Be delighted to give Tino all the minutes he can handle.