General NUFC stuff

[Nucasol]

Best game of 2024: 3-3 v Liverpool

Best goal of 2024: Isak vs Liverpool, December 2024

Best player of 2024: Gordon

Most improved player of 2024: Hall

 

Any other special moments of 2024: The whole run up to the Derby with the Black (and White) Cats bar, their meltdown and subsequent beasting.

 

[PauloGeordio]

 

[Pilko]

Another goal today for Joe White at MK Dons. Seems to be doing well there.

[Fak]

These Football Times latest edition is on NUFC.

 

https://thesefootballtimes.shop/products/newcastle

[LFEE]

 

[M4]

47 minutes 

[PauloGeordio]

I’d been invited up for a New Year’s Eve do and the lad got us tickets for the game. It’s where it all started for me 

[pedro111]

Shearer, Ferdinand and Beardsley man. What a time to be alive.

[joeyt]

The Athletic have done a club by club article of worst Prem decisions and Chris Waugh has picked Keith Stroud against Burton in the Prem for us

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6032908/2025/01/03/referee-decisions-you-cannot-forget/

 

I think I'd have gone for the Livramento handball against PSG last year, or Ederson taking out Fraser and not getting a penalty or Tiote's disallowed goal vs City

[54]

14 minutes ago, joeyt said:

The Athletic have done a club by club article of worst Prem decisions and Chris Waugh has picked Keith Stroud against Burton in the Prem for us

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6032908/2025/01/03/referee-decisions-you-cannot-forget/

 

I think I'd have gone for the Livramento handball against PSG last year, or Ederson taking out Fraser and not getting a penalty or Tiote's disallowed goal vs City

Personally it has to be the Stroud decision for me. The other ones are horrendous, and are worthy of discussion, but they're still in-play decisions that have a degree of subjectivity about them.

 

Keith Stroud simply made up a rule on the spot, it wasn't subjective, it was just flat out incorrect, and was due to his own incompetence of not knowing the rule. 

[SteV]

2 minutes ago, joeyt said:

The Athletic have done a club by club article of worst Prem decisions and Chris Waugh has picked Keith Stroud against Burton in the Prem for us

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6032908/2025/01/03/referee-decisions-you-cannot-forget/

 

I think I'd have gone for the Livramento handball against PSG last year, or Ederson taking out Fraser and not getting a penalty or Tiote's disallowed goal vs City

I think what makes the Burton stand out is that all of the others are lest subjective to some degree, I mean, aye, all blatantly wrong, but for every foul/handball decision you have to interpret what you see and then make a decision. But that night against Burton he just didn’t know the rules, or least forgot them.

[BergenMagpie]

4 minutes ago, joeyt said:

The Athletic have done a club by club article of worst Prem decisions and Chris Waugh has picked Keith Stroud against Burton in the Prem for us

 

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/6032908/2025/01/03/referee-decisions-you-cannot-forget/

 

I think I'd have gone for the Livramento handball against PSG last year, or Ederson taking out Fraser and not getting a penalty or Tiote's disallowed goal vs City

That "double penalty" situation vs sunderland before they went on the counter and got a pen + Colo red card

Also the Boly elbow on Perez when he was just about the head in the winner only for them to get instead

RvP elbow on Cabaye before scoring

 

Jesus - so many bad memories. Tino handball is probably the worst though

[GeordieDazzler]

That Burton one is the maddest thing I’ve seen tbh. 
 

 

[PauloGeordio]