Marc Guehi

[Lotus]

Antonio Silva?

[JigsawGoesToPieces]

Should lowball palace £25m plus add ons

[Checko]

Can't imagine Palace wanting to sell him in January if they're still in a relagation battle, certainly not for less that we'd offered in the summer.

 

That said, I'd take our summer offer, divide it by his remaining contract months at the time, and offer an equivalent amount based on shorter contract, just because.

 

So, say 65 million with 22 months of his contract remaining = 2.95 million per month. Near the end of Jan that's 5 months less on the contract so about £15 million less. £50 million offer.

 

If they accept I'd then withdraw it and offer £45 million, then £40 etc.

[Cf]

On 10/11/2024 at 20:56, Dokko said:

Him still there in the summer and palace relegated would be funny as fuck. Still think thry have too much about them though. Weird how their manager has dropped of a cliff though, he looked proper naughty coming in, with 2 players or so away from a very strong xi.  Olisie is a huge loss. No doubt sbout it. 

 

I think the quality of the league is generally really high that losing a key player makes a huge difference. 

 

Palmer is basically carrying Chelsea. It's not to say they're shit without him but take him away and suddenly they're probably mid table. 

 

See also Rodri at Man City for a higher up the table example. Overwhelming favourites for the league before they lose him for the season. 

 

Makes the job Howe did with most of our first XI out last season all the more impressive imo. 

[andycap]

Palace aren't in a strong position now, they shouldn't have getting greedy. 

Stick 30 million in take it or leave it. 

Or just forget the bugger and go elsewhere. 

[Dokko]

19 minutes ago, Cf said:

 

I think the quality of the league is generally really high that losing a key player makes a huge difference. 

 

Palmer is basically carrying Chelsea. It's not to say they're shit without him but take him away and suddenly they're probably mid table. 

 

See also Rodri at Man City for a higher up the table example. Overwhelming favourites for the league before they lose him for the season. 

 

Makes the job Howe did with most of our first XI out last season all the more impressive imo. 

 

It does actually (Rodri especially) 

[Keegans Export]

On 10/11/2024 at 21:22, STM said:

Got a sneaky feeling we might go back for Tapsoba (spelling).

Summer maybe. He's still got a while on his contract, Leverkusen look to be challenging for CL places and he's played every minute of every game so far. Would take a monumental offer in January I reckon.

[Chris_R]

We'll have Lascelles and Botman back soon after the window opens, our desperation from the summer has gone and Guehi has a lot less left on his contract. Can't imagine for one minute we go back in for him with any kind of big offer. Add in his deep in form too.

 

If we do make an offer it'll be a hell of a lot less than the last one. Shoe's on the other foot this time.

[Paully]

Aye, ferk them and their wanker owners and fans - lowball offer in January please to unsettle him then the ball is in his court! 

 

 

Edited November 12, 2024 by Paully

[ExiledGeordie]

9 hours ago, Paully said:

Aye, ferk them and their wanker owners and fans - lowball offer in January please to unsettle him then the ball is in his court! 

 

 

 

Spot on, if anything just to wind Parish up too. I think it’s unlikely he comes to us now but we clearly like what he has skills wise at the right price. 
 

I think we’ll aim for a RW in Jan, anything else a bonus. I guess if a CB comes available maybe that too but cost wise seems unlikely as I think they’ll spend a fair chunk on the forward line. Botman and Lascelles coming back lessens the urgency at CB too as someone above has already mentioned. 

 

 

Edited November 13, 2024 by ExiledGeordie

[SUPERTOON]

3 hours ago, hakka said:

He will go to Liverpool. I hope we have lots of other options scouted.

We didn’t in the summer.

[r0cafella]

2 minutes ago, SUPERTOON said:

We didn’t in the summer.

Indeed we didn't however Paul Mitchell will not be given 2 windows worth of excuses. 

 

I say this as someone who backed him during the summer debacle as well. 

[Erikse]

Another question is whether we even want to do deals in january, unless it's absolutely necessary. In the window where we signed Gordon, I'm confident Ashby would've been our only signing if Gordon didn't ditch training, despite our push for top 4 at the time.

 

 

Edited November 13, 2024 by Erikse

[ExiledGeordie]

I don’t think the club have afford to sign nobody this January. If we suffer a few key injuries and the squad suffers as a result there’ll be hell on and it could cost us Europe. 

[Erikse]

33 minutes ago, ExiledGeordie said:

I don’t think the club have afford to sign nobody this January. If we suffer a few key injuries and the squad suffers as a result there’ll be hell on and it could cost us Europe. 

 

Sure, but if all the players we go for are being priced too high, we might still wait. I think we tend to focus on the long term when it comes to transfers (despite our accident with PSR), like doing nothing instead of overpaying (like we did with Guehi).

 

 

Edited November 13, 2024 by Erikse

[Sibierski]

17 hours ago, Cf said:

 

I think the quality of the league is generally really high that losing a key player makes a huge difference. 

 

Palmer is basically carrying Chelsea. It's not to say they're shit without him but take him away and suddenly they're probably mid table. 

 

See also Rodri at Man City for a higher up the table example. Overwhelming favourites for the league before they lose him for the season. 

 

Makes the job Howe did with most of our first XI out last season all the more impressive imo. 

Flip side to the above comments too in same post, we didn’t lose Bruno in that period though who was/is instrumental to us. 
 

As for Guehi, there’s little reason to go back in Jan and for Palace now to sell. Summer is the next opportunity, where the figure will be a lot lower anyway.

 

 

Edited November 13, 2024 by Sibierski

[geordiekris]

33 minutes ago, Erikse said:

 

Sure, but if all the players we go for are being priced too high, we might still wait. I think we tend to focus on the long term when it comes to transfers (despite our accident with PSR), like doing nothing instead of overpaying (like we did with Guehi).

 

 

 

This is what I think happens. 
 

I think we'll be quoted too high and the club will use the excuse they do t want to make the same PSR mistakes as last time where they are scurrying around to sell players they don't want to in June. 

[Erikse]

1 hour ago, geordiekris said:

This is what I think happens. 
 

I think we'll be quoted too high and the club will use the excuse they do t want to make the same PSR mistakes as last time where they are scurrying around to sell players they don't want to in June. 

 

I think it's a very real possibility, even if we have several targets. That's why most clubs doesn't buy in january. I don't think it would be an excuse though, the real mistake was to seemingly not have enough targets in the summer. I can understand not wanting to waste money by overpaying in january.

 

 

Edited November 13, 2024 by Erikse

[JEToon]

I would still like us to get him, him and Botman as a CB pair for likely 6 years, box that off and barely have to spend on the defense for a long time, be quite handy.

[andycap]

Whats this Guehi to liverpool lingo? 

I cannot see it to be honest. yeah he could be a free but he's bit small if he's meant to be replacing van dijk. 

And nowhere near as good. 

[Slim]

2 hours ago, andycap said:

Whats this Guehi to liverpool lingo? 

I cannot see it to be honest. yeah he could be a free but he's bit small if he's meant to be replacing van dijk. 

And nowhere near as good. 

The free is is key key word 

[HawK]

Funny to think that if he ever ended up here, and there was a couple of keeper injuries, 4 of the England back 5 could legitimately be Newcastle players.

[nemtizz]

 

[Kilcline]

5 minutes ago, nemtizz said:

 

"Let's have a look at what you could have won" 

[Theregulars]

Yes, they’re going back to Newcastle and you’re in the traffic to Croydon.