WilliamPS

I thought he did very well. Surprised by comments that he drifted in/out as I thought he was busy and very involved in the attacking play. If he does well against Brentford he will keep the starting spot - that is how Howe has tended to work in the past - if you’re playing well you keep the spot.

Of all the reasons not to want a player I’d put being too professional and not agitating for a move down the list. I’d take Guehi at a sensible price - however Palace will probably hold out for something silly, if so best to leave it be

Agree with the posters about the Europa League. That would be a great competition to have a real go at and some fun sides. whereas realistically in the CL you might get some great games but ultimately are only in it to make up the numbers, until Real inevitably win it. However the money and the players desire for CL football mean that has to be the target. I’d be a bit disappointed with the Conference.

Am lucky enough to have been there today. The emotion when the ball hit the back of the net and then at full time was indescribable. Funny change from 2023, in the pubs after that there were songs and chants, and deep conversations on tactics and moments - today afterwards was much quieter - just people beaming. Defeat has a million causes to discuss, whereas winning, we won, so much less to say The only cloud is I bloody wish they’d beaten Brighton in the fa cup even more now.

The mornings before are such dead time ! I know some will get on the drink but I’m way too old for that - I’d sleep through the game. Back in 98 I went to the British museum, and wasn’t the only toon fan in there.

no “going up”? Bunch of philistines

These are the 4 that we need to do the business

Devils advocate on Henderson is the squad looked miserable at the euros so maybe he’s basically there as a senior pro. Theres always a few players in the squad who never play or only get 5 mins at the end. Big question for me is what is he going to do with Foden, Bellingham, Kane and Palmer. I think you struggle to fit any two of them together, never mind 4. And if he’s going for Kane then he needs to put pace in behind - Gordon one side and someone else RW, and that only leaves midfield slots for the others. Is he going to make the big calls that Southgate ducked

There’s always touts selling outside the ground so I guess they flog them there, and are seasoned enough to know at what time to cut their prices

Yeah I’d hold off lolling about penalty failures until after the match

I think this is only true to a certain extent. Players want to win trophies, and the narrative around Newcastle will be “go there and you’ll never win anything”. That has to change if you want to attract and retain the best players The example to avoid is Spurs, who everyone would agree are the bottom of the big six pack, despite being financially competitive and having years in the CL, as the others actually win things.

Makes the CL more interesting, if Real Madrid can be despatched tomorrow be a fun next round. I doubt playing 120 mins on a Tuesday will impact Liverpool on Sunday mind.

League position is now on a knife edge, cock up the next few games and could be down at 8th or 9th, recover a run of form and CL is achievable…it is hard to be confident at the moment though

It’s sensible that the club have succession plans for all players. I hope isaks succession plan isn’t needed for a few years yet

Schar has played 41, 47 and 30 (so far) games last 3 seasons. If Wilson had that sort of availability giving him a new contract would also be a done deal.

Schar-Burn isn’t working very well at the moment, but it’s a combination that’s supposed to play 10 games a season, not 50. They are both going to the wall for the club this season as they are the only consistently fit CBs. Schar is a good player and it would be brainless to let him go in the summer, even with new signings

Th income numbers and staffing show the club is now ran as a serious enterprise. A long way to go, but clearly moving in the right direction

Harsh judgements given the quality of the chances created and the speed of the build ups

I don’t think it’s an average team at all, that’s why it’s so frustrating. But there is a big difference in quality within the team now and there is some insane decision making going on with some of the weaker players. Schar-Burn for me doesn’t work anymore. We all know RCB is a priority position and Botman is injured but it is costing the team. I don’t blame the players or the manager and the club do want to fix it, but that’s the reality. Got away with Murphy in the first half of the season but his form had dried up a bit and he makes some terrible choices in his own half.

It should have been over in the first half.

Need to give Wilson a single decent chance. Wilson or Wellbeck will settle this.

This will get nice and toxic!

A vital 3 points but somehow I am now less confident of CL than before the game

It’s ever since the Liverpool game against ten men. Too many subs left the team disjointed and they capitalised, Howe has been wary of too many changes ever since

I’m not getting involved in this debate - but this is a very important point! If they've got Shrek THE MUSICAL all bets are off!