James Perch

[ChrisMcQuillan]

When he ran the ball out of play at the start out a counter attack, I wanted to walk down and smash his head in myself.

[The Prophet]

UTTER UTTER s***

Goes mossing all the fkn time.. play Ryan Taylor until Simpson is back.

 

Got a green thumb has he?

[joeyt]

Could argue he was at fault for the first goal. Why the f**k did he just run out of play giving away a needless throw-in?

[Guest Mani]

Could argue he was at fault for the first goal. Why the f**k did he just run out of play giving away a needless throw-in?

 

exactly, he wud have been told aswell before the game that giving away throwings is like giving away corners when yr playing stoke. 

 

 

[Pilko]

Could argue he was at fault for the first goal. Why the f**k did he just run out of play giving away a needless throw-in?

 

Because he's rubbish

[Tooj]

The thing is, you can tell every time he's involved he's thinking he's not good enough to be playing at this level, it really does show.

 

He's honest like, I'll give him that. At least he isn't a coward and hides like Ryan Taylor does.

[geordiemonster]

He was utterly awful today.  Apart from the fact he was at fault for the first and scored the second his all round game was not that of a premier league defender.

[Guest palnese]

Please sell him in January. He wasn't even a regular at Forest ffs.

[JH]

He's really been thrown in at the deep end. I can't help but think if we'd signed him last time we were interested, some time in the Championship and being promoted with us might have been an easier way to settle him in.

 

He's relatively young and this is the highest level he's played at, it's no surprise he's making mistakes.

[midds]

First position that needs strengthening in January is this finding someone to replace this muppet. Simpson is wank but less shit than this fucker.

 

Complete liability. 

[James]

First position that needs strengthening in January is this finding someone to replace this muppet. Simpson is wank but less shit than this fucker.

 

Complete liability. 

 

Striker first. No good having a good defence if we can't find the back of the net.

[midds]

First position that needs strengthening in January is this finding someone to replace this muppet. Simpson is wank but less shit than this fucker.

 

Complete liability. 

 

Striker first. No good having a good defence if we can't find the back of the net.

 

He's our poorest player and the one being targetted every game by the opposition. He's costing us goals, games and points.

 

Striker is number 2, granted.

[MF3]

Aye, caught that I had put first goal and edited the post. Yeah, against anyone else it wouldn't have mattered, but sadly we were playing Stoke today so it did matter. It was akin to just dribbling the ball out for a corner. I know it's harsh to suggest that the 2nd goal was ultimately all his fault (set it up and scored it).

 

No, you were right it was the 1st. Just walked the ball out of play completely unchallenged. From the throw in Stoke get the ball across the pitch, Fuller throws himself down and does himself an injury - they score from the free-kick. I know he's only had 6 games but....he's not very good is he?

[Thespence]

He looks good when he marks a winger who does not cross or shoot that way he can keep getting stuck into him.

[dcmk]

I actually rate him, I believe there is a good player in there - he has played well in most of our matches but has just been punished for a couple of silly mistakes. 

 

When he cuts those errors out, he will be an asset.

[Teasy]

Didn't he give the ball away needlessly in the lead up to the first goal?  Partially causes the first goal and scores the second, Stokes best player on the night.

[Thespence]

I actually rate him, I believe there is a good player in there - he has played well in most of our matches but has just has been punished for a couple of silly mistakes. 

 

When he cuts those errors out, he will be an asset.

 

I agree if he cuts the errors out , he will be an asset.

 

 

[Segun Oluwaniyi]

I actually rate him, I believe there is a good player in there - he has played well in most of our matches but has just has been punished for a couple of silly mistakes. 

 

When he cuts those errors out, he will be an asset.

I agree that he has all the tools, but he's 25 years old in a few days. If he was going to be very good, that side would have shown it self by now. He's an average Championship player.

[mozy]

He had a solid game today.

[Dokko]

Perch's job this season is to get used to the pace and standard of the prem, his cards show already that its been tough, but some of his performances show its not an impossible task.

 

The clubs job is to make sure next season we have a RB better than a seasoned Perch and Perch is there as backup (for RB, CM & Def mid as well as LB) we got quite cheap and on a low contract, its something the club has struggled with for years, depth in numbers, while supporting positions with tested players not 19 year olds who've not played 90mins in the prem.

 

I'd hope the same can be said for Routledge, backup to a new right winger next season.

 

 

 

 

[Pilko]

Perch has gained a reputation as being a player who can plumb new levels of ineptitude for Newcastle United.

 

 

[Cronky]

He seems a quiet lad who lacks confidence. I don't think I've seen him open his mouth yet. He needs to be more aggressive, because with that spirit even if you don't get the ball, you can do enough to put your opponent off. Against Wolves and today, he allowed himself to be bullied.

 

I felt a bit sorry for him today, because he has improved, game on game.

[Skirge]

Didn't he give the ball away needlessly in the lead up to the first goal?  Partially causes the first goal and scores the second, Stokes best player on the night.

 

Ran it out for the throw in when under no pressure

[Guest sittingontheball]

I didn't realise he is nearly 25. The older he is, the less benefit of the doubt you have to give him.

 

Carroll's also lacking service, so I'd give Ryan Taylor a try.

[ElDiablo]

At home RTaylor should definitely play, Perch is decent but going forward he's quite poor and we need more than that.