Jump to content

Newcastle 1-1 Watford - post match reaction from page 7


Greg

Recommended Posts

Schar is top quality, shouldn’t be anywhere near this club

 

He's not very good at defending, which is brilliant because if he was he certainly wouldn't be here.

 

Schar is a good defender. Very good at times, in fact.

 

He really isn't. He is good at aggresive interceptions at that is about it, he gets caught out of position a lot but gets away with it in our three man set up with relatively deep wing backs making a 5 when defending.

 

Wouldn't have him anywhere near my team in a back four.

 

Great on the ball, lovely passing range. Decent finisher.

 

Schar is top quality, shouldn’t be anywhere near this club

 

He's not very good at defending, which is brilliant because if he was he certainly wouldn't be here.

 

Schar is a good defender. Very good at times, in fact.

 

He's not at all.  If he was he'd be at a very top club

 

I completely disagree. Superb defensively just 1 week ago. Some great challenges.

 

Last ditch tackles and blocks are not the sign of a good defender. :lol:

 

The best defenders don't tackle at all really. They don't need to.

 

This.  Never saw woodgate making them

 

But the likes of Terry, Vidic and Cannavaro do.

 

Occasionally, and you remember them more. Not all the time.

 

The best players are great at them, but rarely need to do them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Schar is top quality, shouldn’t be anywhere near this club

 

He's not very good at defending, which is brilliant because if he was he certainly wouldn't be here.

 

Schar is a good defender. Very good at times, in fact.

 

He really isn't. He is good at aggresive interceptions at that is about it, he gets caught out of position a lot but gets away with it in our three man set up with relatively deep wing backs making a 5 when defending.

 

Wouldn't have him anywhere near my team in a back four.

 

Great on the ball, lovely passing range. Decent finisher.

 

Schar is top quality, shouldn’t be anywhere near this club

 

He's not very good at defending, which is brilliant because if he was he certainly wouldn't be here.

 

Schar is a good defender. Very good at times, in fact.

 

He's not at all.  If he was he'd be at a very top club

 

I completely disagree. Superb defensively just 1 week ago. Some great challenges.

 

Last ditch tackles and blocks are not the sign of a good defender. :lol:

 

The best defenders don't tackle at all really. They don't need to.

 

This.  Never saw woodgate making them

 

But the likes of Terry, Vidic and Cannavaro do.

 

Occasionally, and you remember them more. Not all the time.

 

The best players are great at them, but rarely need to do them.

 

Aye it’s not black and white though.  So many different styles of play.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest neesy111

44,157

 

minus unused away allocation (over 4000 allocated)

 

minus stay away season ticket holders

 

EDTbkhlXUAAQO4D?format=jpg&name=4096x4096

 

So based on that id guess that at least 2k Watford seats were empty bringing the attendance down to 42k max

 

That can't be right.  No club counts empty unsold tickets as sold for tax purposes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't buy this 'if he was that good he wouldn't be here' bollocks, plenty of shit defenders at top clubs and good ones at others. Having said that he maybe gives away too many fouls and isn't teh quickest? However I think he's class.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...