Eddie Howe - Granted Freedom of Newcastle

[Gallowgate Toon]

6 minutes ago, Pilko said:

 

Because we all sat here and said "The squad is terrible but Bruce is the fucking pits, this team would be doing better under someone even halfway competent".

 

And Howe has come in, and made absolutely no impact whatsoever other than stumbling upon Joelinton being a canny CM (which he only discovered by starting Clark, another Howe mistake).

 

The narrative seems to have shifted from "squad shit, Bruce making it worse" to "squad so shit that nobody in the world could fix it" just so people can defend Eddie Howe. He's hoodwinked so many on this forum and it's plain as day he's not up to the job.

At best, this current squad is 15th in the league. 

 

It has absolutely massive deficiencies across the whole lot and the core has had a habit of being diabolical for long stretches. That includes Rafa's time here.

 

What would you be doing differently?

[54]

1 minute ago, Pilko said:

 

Because we all sat here and said "The squad is terrible but Bruce is the fucking pits, this team would be doing better under someone even halfway competent".

 

And Howe has come in, and made absolutely no impact whatsoever other than stumbling upon Joelinton being a canny CM (which he only discovered by starting Clark, another Howe mistake).

 

The narrative seems to have shifted from "squad shit, Bruce making it worse" to "squad so shit that nobody in the world could fix it" just so people can defend Eddie Howe. He's hoodwinked so many on this forum and it's plain as day he's not up to the job.

On the flip side to this, there can be a bit more nuisance than "He's shite" or "he's great" and people can have different opinions, there can be a shade of grey. I personally have seen a marked improvement in the team since he's arrived, tactically we have been much better, and in every game there has been a clear gameplan and under different circumstances we would be out of the relegation zone right now, but Howe's game management has been a bit of a miss then a hit, and has probably cost us points, it doesnt always have to be to the extremes.

 

You seem to like accusing people of backing him to the hilt, that he's "Hoodwinked" people but you cant seem to realize that your own viewpoint is also too far the other way.

[matta]

Eddie needs us to catch some form. Basically no change where it matters. Points.

 

 

Edited January 15, 2022 by matta

[Tsunami]

19 minutes ago, ManDoon said:

I’m not massively ITK or anything but I’ve heard nothing good about our scouting .

I’ve heard poor reports as well. I believe Nickson needs to go and we need that side of things completely rebuilt. It sounds League 1 level at the moment 

[Thiago]

15 minutes ago, Pilko said:

 

Because we all sat here and said "The squad is terrible but Bruce is the fucking pits, this team would be doing better under someone even halfway competent".

 

And Howe has come in, and made absolutely no impact whatsoever other than stumbling upon Joelinton being a canny CM (which he only discovered by starting Clark, another Howe mistake).

 

The narrative seems to have shifted from "squad shit, Bruce making it worse" to "squad so shit that nobody in the world could fix it" just so people can defend Eddie Howe. He's hoodwinked so many on this forum and it's plain as day he's not up to the job.

You're not wrong Pilko, but that suggests we're starting from game one. 

 

That useless old bag of shite that is Steve Bruce chewed up some very winnable games himself. Southampton, Watford, Tottenham are just three examples. I honestly think if he'd won against Brentford he'd have believed in his ideas and we'd be 5-10 points better off. 

[worthy]

1 minute ago, ManDoon said:

Yeah it’s fucking dreadful. I find it insane they have access to the whole of football and the best they could do was Chris Wood?. It’s not good at all 

Well from what has been said, its what Howe wanted, a big man.

[Sandrotastico]

If you add a Kamara or Fofana next to Joelinton.

 

Bin Shelvey and allow Schar to do the Hollywood passing.

Bin Longstaff and play Maxi off Wood :/ then get two out and out wingers on the pitch.

I'd go Murphy Right and Ritchie Left.

 

Get crosses in, let Maxi feed off Wood and let Joe and a Midfielder with an engine boss the midfield.

 

We seem to have 3 players doing the job 2 because 2 of them are fucking shit.

 

[macphisto]

2 minutes ago, ManDoon said:

Yeah it’s fucking dreadful. I find it insane they have access to the whole of football and the best they could do was Chris Wood?. It’s not good at all 

I think a lot of the motivation for Wood was to weaken Burnley.

[SUPERTOON]

Looks like Rafa could be available tonight.

[Elephant]

Do you honestly think Emery would have said yes to Chris Wood? Or Rafa?

 

Howe said yes, because obviously manager has to accept the signings. And for me that’s very concerning.

 

We can’t sign big names like Coutinho or Digne because Howe is not attracting manager. And right now we need class more than anything else.

[Geordie Ahmed]

21 minutes ago, Pilko said:

 

Because we all sat here and said "The squad is terrible but Bruce is the fucking pits, this team would be doing better under someone even halfway competent".

 

And Howe has come in, and made absolutely no impact whatsoever other than stumbling upon Joelinton being a canny CM (which he only discovered by starting Clark, another Howe mistake).

 

The narrative seems to have shifted from "squad shit, Bruce making it worse" to "squad so shit that nobody in the world could fix it" just so people can defend Eddie Howe. He's hoodwinked so many on this forum and it's plain as day he's not up to the job.

No impact whatsoever is a bit harsh imo, I understand the late equaliser hurts and emotions are running high

 

Bruce had 3 points from 8 games, across a full season that's 14.25 points

 

Howe has 7 points from 9 games, across a full season that's 29.55 points 

 

So there is an improvement, unfortunately it's not enough of an improvement 

 

Plus you add in this isn't his squad, I'm willing to reserve judgement on him 

 

[Jackie Broon]

Just now, macphisto said:

I think a lot of the motivation for Wood was to weaken Burnley.

 

Just before they play Watford, who are the team we'll need to finish above to stay up. Burnley are going down whatever.

[Collage]

25 minutes ago, macphisto said:

Each to their own but he doesn't to me. Indeed, I find him quite bland. He's well presented, probably had good media training as he talks well enough but that's not charisma in my book.

Not sure ”charisma” is an important quality for a manager, it’s more something we on the outside care about as we don’t see how a manager is on the training pitch, in the locker room and so on.

[SUPERTOON]

I’m intrigued to see what type of owners we have btw, as in are they utterly ruthless in managerial situations. Obviously everything we have seen so far suggests they aren’t.

[Elephant]

Just now, Geordie Ahmed said:

Howe has 7 points from 9 games, across a full season that's 29.55 points 

 

So there is an improvement, unfortunately it's not enough of an improvement 

 

 When you look at our opponents, you realize it’s not good at all. We are not going to have these easy games, because we blew almost every single of them with poor results. 
 

We’ve had opportunity to gain points from the weakest teams and we have not done it.

 

Brentford, Norwich and Watford home, no wins in these games.

 

Stats of 29.55 points looks pretty crap when you think about who we have played against.

 

Only two positive results and honestly winning Burnley home 1-0 is not exactly win of the season.

 

 

[Geordie Ahmed]

4 minutes ago, Elephant said:

 When you look at our opponents, you realize it’s not good at all. We are not going to have these easy games, because we blew almost every single of them with poor results. 
 

We’ve had opportunity to gain points from the weakest teams and we have not done it.

 

Brentford, Norwich and Watford home, no wins in these games.

 

Stats of 29.55 points looks pretty crap when you think about who we have played against.

 

Only two positive results and honestly winning Burnley home 1-0 is not exactly win of the season.

 

 

I'm not saying 29.55 is great, I'm just pointing out that in comparison to Bruce it's better 

 

Let's not forget we had a decent set of fixtures under Bruce too but he blew in, that's where the foundation of our problems started 

[toon25]

11 minutes ago, Elephant said:

 When you look at our opponents, you realize it’s not good at all. We are not going to have these easy games, because we blew almost every single of them with poor results. 
 

We’ve had opportunity to gain points from the weakest teams and we have not done it.

 

Brentford, Norwich and Watford home, no wins in these games.

 

Stats of 29.55 points looks pretty crap when you think about who we have played against.

 

Only two positive results and honestly winning Burnley home 1-0 is not exactly win of the season.

 

 

We've also been absolutely fucking shite when we've played the better teams, so added to the inability to get results against direct rivals, we look nowhere near getting a surprise result that would get us points on the board.

[macphisto]

5 minutes ago, Collage said:

Not sure ”charisma” is an important quality for a manager, it’s more something we on the outside care about as we don’t see how a manager is on the training pitch, in the locker room and so on.

Completely disagree, I think it's the most important quality in a manager. All the top managers have it, looking at our own history you only have to look at Keegan, particularly Keegan, and Bobby Robson. Further afield look at Klopp now or Clough in the past. All those managers have/had the ability to lift players and make them feel they could win any game through their natural personality/enthusiasm/charisma to inspire players.

 

There's a load of top managers who leave training to their assistants and the reason they are where they are is through their charisma and ability to motivate players (all connected to man management). 

 

Howe has spectacularly failed to lift the mentality/inspire the team. There's been no significant difference.

 

[Andy]

10 minutes ago, Geordie Ahmed said:

I'm not saying 29.55 is great, I'm just pointing out that in comparison to Bruce it's better 

 

Let's not forget we had a decent set of fixtures under Bruce too but he blew in, that's where the foundation of our problems started 

 

We're drawing games that we would lose under Bruce, unfortunately that's not enough of an improvement. 

[Geordie Ahmed]

Just now, Andy said:

 

We're drawing games that we would lose under Bruce, unfortunately that's not enough of an improvement. 

I agree with that, the improvement has not been enough

 

I'm just not ready to start calling for Howe to go, far too soon for that and I think ultimately he was chosen because when we go down then he has experience of getting promoted from The Championship 

[Guest HTT II]

He’s taking us down…

[TRon]

50 minutes ago, Pilko said:

 

Because we all sat here and said "The squad is terrible but Bruce is the fucking pits, this team would be doing better under someone even halfway competent".

 

And Howe has come in, and made absolutely no impact whatsoever other than stumbling upon Joelinton being a canny CM (which he only discovered by starting Clark, another Howe mistake).

 

The narrative seems to have shifted from "squad shit, Bruce making it worse" to "squad so shit that nobody in the world could fix it" just so people can defend Eddie Howe. He's hoodwinked so many on this forum and it's plain as day he's not up to the job.

 

He didn't stumble upon Joelinton like, he was pointing out his technical abilities like good footwork under pressure even before he put him in midfield. By all means you can have a go at him if you feel he's getting things wrong, but you have to give him credit for what he's got right. 

[Minhosa]

1 hour ago, Vinny Green Balls said:

One again, man, we are not having a go at different opinions. How many times do we have to mention this. KI just alluded to this. And you keep on defending some of them as if we are oppressing them. FWIW, I was never attacking you. I never even had you in mind. If anything, I just find it strange that it is almost the exact people doing this, with the exception of Pilko, who defended Rafa at the time.

 

 

 

You say this every week, why don't you just name the people you're digging out so they have the right to reply?

[Awaymag]

I so want Howe to succeed and with Dummet on the pitch we looked so much better....but

 

I dont really see a style of play yet.  Lascelles is done for me, he cant defend and he cant pass.  We so need a top defensive midfielder,  we concede so much terrority its untrue.

 

Howe, I hope comes good but I think we are down and I wonder if they will stick with him?

[AJ9]

If Rafa is available, Howe should be binned, stat. I am obviously biased because I love Rafa, but he is better than Howe, despite having a shit time at Everton. Another clear benefit is that he knows exactly what it takes to win the championship, and would back him to take us straight back up again.